On the eighth of September an important officer entered the coach house with a paper, named Pierre as the man who does not give his name, and ordered the prisoners decently dressed before they were taken to the marshal. An hour later Pierre and thirteen others were led to the Virgin's Field. After rain the air was unusually pure. Smoke rose in columns; Moscow as far as he could see was charred ruin, stoves and chimney stacks, blackened brick, a few unburned churches. The Kremlin gleamed white; bells of the New Convent of the Virgin rang for Sunday and the Nativity, yet only tattered, frightened Russians tried to hide when they saw the French. Pierre felt a firm French order established over the ruined nest: marching ranks, an official in a carriage, merry regimental music, and the list that had not forgotten him.
They took him to Prince Shcherbatov's white house, now occupied by Marshal Davout, the Duke of Eckmuhl. Pierre was the sixth to enter the long low study. Davout, spectacles on nose, asked who he was without looking up. Pierre could not speak. Davout raised his head, said he knew that man, and told another general Pierre was a Russian spy. Pierre pleaded that he was a militia officer named Bezukhov who had not left Moscow. For some seconds they looked at one another, and that look established human relations outside war and law. Davout asked for proof. Pierre named Ramballe, his regiment, and the street of the house.
An adjutant entered with news that made Davout brighten and button his uniform. Reminded of the prisoner, he frowned, jerked his head, and ordered Pierre led away. Pierre did not know whether they were taking him back to the coach house or to the place of execution his companions had pointed out on the Virgin's Field. His faculties went numb. The only thought left was who had really sentenced him. Not the first commission, not Davout who had looked at him as a man, not the adjutant who had merely come in. It was no one. A system, a concurrence of circumstances, was annihilating him.
Chapter ten leads Pierre through ruins to Shcherbatov house, Davout spy accusation, brother look, Ramballe proof, adjutant erasure. Andrew should pair system without agent with execution witness chapter. Andrew should pair system without agent with execution where who disappears. Tolstoy shows how private feeling survives when public language hardens around it. Tolstoy shows how private feeling survives when public language hardens around it.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion