The officer and soldiers who arrested Pierre treated him with hostility and yet with respect, still unsure whether this big man in a peasant coat might be someone important after the fight over the child. Next morning the relief saw only prisoner Number 17, detained by order of the Higher Command. They noticed his French and his meditative stare, then put him with the other suspects because an officer needed the separate room. The Russians confined with him were of the lowest class. Recognising a gentleman who spoke French, they avoided him and made fun of him, which made Pierre sad.
On the third day he was taken with the others before a French general with a white moustache, two colonels, and men wearing scarves. The questions, like trial questions generally, left the essence aside and formed a channel meant to lead to conviction. Whenever Pierre said anything that did not fit, they cut him off. He answered that he had been restoring a child saved from the flames, that he had protected a woman, that he had gone out to see what was happening in Moscow. They had not asked where he was going, but why he was found near the fire, and who he was. He would not give his name. The flushed general marked it down as bad, very bad.
On the fourth day fires broke out on the Zubovski rampart. Pierre and thirteen others were moved to a merchant's coach house near the Crimean bridge. Smoke hung over the city; he looked at the fires with horror without yet grasping what the burning of Moscow meant. From French talk he learned they all awaited a decision from the marshal, a high and mysterious power whose name the soldiers would not make clear. Those first days, before the second examination on the eighth of September, were the hardest of all for him.
Book Twelve chapter nine strips Pierre's identity, stages hollow examination, moves him to coach house as Moscow burns. Andrew should read predetermined trial pattern before Davout and execution chapters. Andrew should read predetermined trial before Davout names the man who gives no name. Tolstoy shows how private feeling survives when public language hardens around it. Tolstoy shows how private feeling survives when public language hardens around it.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion