From Shcherbatov's house the prisoners were led down the Virgin's Field to a kitchen garden near the nunnery where a post and a fresh pit waited. A mixed crowd of Russians and off-duty Germans, Italians, and Frenchmen stood in a semicircle; troops in blue with red epaulets lined both sides. Pierre was sixth on the list. Drums began to beat, and he felt as if part of his soul had been torn away. He could only hear and see, wishing the frightful thing would happen quickly. The first two were convicts with shaven heads, then a plump domestic serf, a handsome peasant with a light-brown beard, and a thin factory lad of eighteen. The French decided to shoot them in couples. An official read the sentence in Russian and in French.
Soldiers bound the two convicts to the post and drew sacks over their heads. Twelve sharpshooters halted eight paces away. Pierre turned aside, then a crackling louder than thunder made him look: smoke, pale Frenchmen with trembling hands at the pit. Two more were led up with the same silent appeal in their eyes. Again he turned away; again the explosion, smoke, blood, and the same dismay on every Russian and French face. Who, after all, was doing this if they were all suffering as he was? The fifth prisoner, the factory lad next to Pierre, was led away alone. Pierre did not understand that he and the rest had been brought only to witness. The lad clutched him, screamed, then grew quiet at the bloodstained post, adjusted the knot himself, and settled his feet. Pierre could no longer close his eyes.
He did not afterwards remember the shots, only the workman sinking on the cords, blood in two places, the body collapsing into the pit while one shoulder still rose and fell as earth was thrown over it. A young sharpshooter stood swaying by the pit, musket on the ground, until an old noncommissioned officer dragged him back. The crowd dispersed with drooping heads. A Frenchman muttered that this would teach them to start fires, then broke off with a hopeless movement of his arm.
Chapter eleven is Tolstoy's harrowing paired shootings, factory lad, Pierre witness not victim, soldier's failed justification. Andrew should read ritual violence trauma before Karataev restoration. Andrew should hold ritual violence trauma before Karataev potatoes restore Pierre. Tolstoy shows how private feeling survives when public language hardens around it. Tolstoy shows how private feeling survives when public language hardens around it.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion