Borís has not made a wealthy match in Petersburg, so he comes to Moscow with the same object and wavers between the two richest heiresses. Mary, despite her plainness, seems more attractive, yet he feels awkward: on the old prince's name day she answered at random, not listening. Julie, twenty-seven, now decidedly plain but sure she is more attractive than before, accepts his attentions in her own manner. After her brothers' deaths she is very wealthy. Men who would once have feared compromising a girl of seventeen now treat her as a sexless acquaintance and enjoy her midnight suppers.
That winter the Karágins' house is the most hospitable in Moscow. Julie never misses a ball, yet tells everyone she believes in neither friendship nor love and expects peace only yonder, a performed disappointment she has come to believe. Visitors pay tribute to her melancholy, then amuse themselves with bouts rimés. Borís goes deeper: he sketches rustic trees that shed gloom, a tomb with French lines on death as refuge, and verses to tender melancholy. She plays doleful harp nocturnes; he reads Poor Liza aloud and interrupts, choked. Anna Mikháylovna, playing cards with the mother, inventories two Pénza estates and the Nizhegórod forests, pities the poor woman who is cheated, and calls Julie an angelic being. Borís smiles at the naïve diplomacy and questions her carefully about the income he has already apportioned in his mind.
Julie has long expected a proposal, but a secret repulsion at her powdered chin, moist eyes, and readiness to leap from melancholy into married rapture still restrains him. Every day he tells himself he will propose tomorrow. Then Anatole Kurágin appears in her drawing room; she abandons melancholy and becomes cheerful and attentive. Anna Mikháylovna warns that Prince Vasíli has sent his son to marry Julie. The thought of that month of arduous service and those revenues falling to Anatole pains Borís. He drives over intending to propose, speaks irritably of feminine inconstancy, then checks himself, blushes, and says she knows his feelings. She forces him to say he has never loved another more. The affianced pair drop gloom for a splendid Petersburg house, paid calls, and a brilliant wedding, and no more melancholy verses.
Tolstoy exposes the marriage market without moralizing aloud. Julie, plain and rich, hosts midnight suppers where sadness is costume. Boris supplies trees, tomb verses, and choked readings of Poor Liza because Penza and Nizhegorod forests are already apportioned in his mind. Anna Mikhaylovna plays diplomat-cardshark, praising angelic Julie while auditing accounts. Attraction to Mary was real but unsafe; her distraction on name day signaled she would not play. Anatole's grin ends the play: Julie cheers up, Boris snarls about feminine inconstancy, then checks himself because unfinished business is intolerable to him. The proposal is revulsion converted to triumph. Immediately melancholy trees become a Petersburg house. Andrew should see parallel in missions: charm campaigns toward funders, performative empathy reports, panic yes when a rival mission shop appears. The lesson is not cynicism about love; it is literacy about theater that lands deeds. If your institution rewards begun must finish, you will marry Julie while despising her chin. Stop early.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion