Astley asks whether Polina likes flowers, and Alexei cannot say. He has never noticed. The Englishman, who would rather lift his hat and pass than sit with them, nods as if an idea has pleased him, and walks off. Alexei, who cannot leave her, has been watching everyone else.
She has avoided him for two days, and the coolness is the old one, with the contempt left visible. She does not hide that he is necessary, or that she is keeping him for an end. She lets him speak of his love. The permission is the insult, because it shows how little she regards what he feels. When a risky errand needs doing she tells him only what a temporary tool would have to know. He may ask. She does not answer, and sometimes she does not notice him. He has known for three weeks that she means to play roulette through his hands, and that money is not the whole of the end. Meanwhile a telegram about the General's mother has sat unanswered for four days. The Frenchman, who last year found thirty thousand roubles for the General's Treasury dues, now talks like a guest who has put his feet on the table, and he is short even with Polina. Blanche is called rich, and a cousin, and she has a face Alexei is afraid of. If the news comes that the grandmother is not dead, he expects Blanche to vanish. He watches her anyway, loathes the watching, and stays, because leaving would mean leaving Polina.
The wire from Petersburg is still unanswered. Astley is somewhere on the next path, pleased about flowers. Blanche's stay depends on a death that has not been confirmed.
Dostoevsky understood something devastating about human psychology: the more we invest in something, the harder it becomes to walk away, even when that investment is destroying us. The narrator sees Polina's contempt clearly, yet stays because leaving would mean admitting his devotion was worthless. This 'sunk cost fallacy' doesn't just apply to gambling—it's the mechanism that keeps people trapped in toxic jobs, abusive relationships, and exploitative situations across all areas of life. In 1867 Russia, social mobility was nearly impossible, so people clung desperately to any chance of advancement, even illusory ones. Today, while we have more options, the psychological trap remains identical. We tell ourselves 'I've already put three years into this job' or 'We've been together for five years' as if time invested guarantees future value. But investment without reciprocity isn't commitment—it's exploitation. The most insidious part is how the exploiter doesn't need to be consciously manipulative. They might genuinely believe their own promises while consistently failing to deliver. The pattern works because it hijacks our natural tendency to avoid waste and our deep fear of starting over. Recognizing this trap requires brutal honesty about whether you're staying because the situation serves you or because you're afraid to lose what you've already given. Sometimes the bravest thing you can do is admit that what you've invested is gone and refuse to throw more after it.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion