Vivaldo reads Chrysostom's Lay of Despair aloud: a discord wrung from bitterness, jealousy, absence, and a stanza in which the dead man admits he is self-deluding yet still calls her injustice the cause that makes him quit the life he loathes. The listeners notice that the poem's suspicions do not match what they have heard of Marcela's reserve. Ambrosio explains that Chrysostom wrote it in voluntary absence, so the imaginary fears leave her virtue unshaken and leave only the charge of being cruel, somewhat haughty, and very scornful.
Then Marcela appears on the summit of the rock where they are digging, so beautiful that her beauty exceeds its reputation. Ambrosio greets her as a basilisk come to watch blood flow. She answers that she has come to defend herself. Heaven made her beautiful without her asking; being loved does not bind the loved to love back; a viper is not blamed for the poison nature gave it; she is a fire afar off, a sword laid aside. She gave no hope to Chrysostom or to any other. On this very spot she told him her purpose was perpetual solitude, and if after that open avowal he steered against the wind, his own obstinacy sank him. Let him who calls her wild beast leave her alone; she neither loves nor hates anyone, and if anyone dies for her it is not of jealousy, for she who loves no one can give no cause for it.
Some of those wounded by her eyes move to follow her anyway. Don Quixote lays his hand on his sword and forbids anyone, whatever his rank, to pursue her, saying she has shown that little or no fault is hers for Chrysostom's death. Whether from his threats or from Ambrosio's reminder of duty, none stir until the grave is finished, the remaining papers burned, and the body laid under a heavy stone. The epitaph still names an ungrateful, cruel, coy, and fair woman who drove him to despair. Vivaldo and his companion press Quixote toward Seville, where adventures present themselves in every street. He will not go until he has cleared these mountains of highwaymen. Then he resolves to seek Marcela and offer her all the service he can, though the history says things did not fall out as he expected.
Vivaldo reads Chrysostom's Lay of Despair aloud: jealousy, tyranny, and a stanza where the dead man admits he is self-deluding yet still calls Marcela's refusal injustice. The listeners notice the poem accuses her of absence and suspicion that do not match her reported virtue. Ambrosio explains those torments were imaginary, born when Chrysostom tested himself with voluntary absence. Marcela appears on the rock above the open grave. Ambrosio calls her basilisk and enemy of the race. She answers with a defence that has become famous: being loved does not oblige one to love back; beauty was heaven's gift, not her choice; she gave no hope to Chrysostom; his obstinacy, not her cruelty, killed him; and clear refusal is not homicide. Cervantes makes the cost visible: not only what the characters suffer, but what bystanders must decide once the story can no longer stay private. The chapter asks whether comfort, silence, or intervention is the truer form of care when someone is living inside a plot of their own.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion