LIVE
OCD← Home
Das Kapital cover
1867
Das Kapital
Karl Marx · The Rate of Surplus-Value
Chapter 9
Ch. 8
Reading
Ch. 9
Ch. 10
Loading audio...
0:000:00

Marx starts with a capital of £500 and gives it a shape: £410 laid out on means of production, which he calls constant, and £90 on labour-power, which he calls variable. When the work is done the product is worth £590, so the surplus-value is £90. But the new value made in the process is only £180, the £90 of wages plus the £90 of surplus, because the £410 only reappears in the product. So Marx sets constant capital to zero, as people do every day when they work out England's profit from cotton and first take off what was paid to the United States, India and Egypt for the raw cotton. What is left is the part that changes, and he measures surplus-value against that part alone. £90 over £90 is 100 per cent. He calls this the rate of surplus-value.

The rate tells you how a working day is split. Part of the day, say six hours, the worker produces only the value of his own wage. Marx calls this necessary labour. The rest is surplus-labour. The worker still labours, but he creates no value for himself, only surplus-value, which for the capitalist has all the charms of a creation out of nothing. Surplus-value is simply that extra time set solid. So the rate of surplus-value equals surplus-labour divided by necessary labour, and it is the exact degree of exploitation. The usual way of reckoning compares the £90 with the whole £500 and gets 18 per cent, a figure that would give Mr. Carey and the other harmonisers a pleasant surprise. The real rate is more than five times that. In the example the worker spends one half of the day for himself and the other half for the capitalist. Marx tests the method on a Manchester mill with 10,000 spindles in April 1871. Cotton, wear, rent and coal come to £378 a week, wages to £52, and the yarn is sold for £510. The surplus is £80, a rate of about 153 per cent, which in a ten-hour day is under four hours of necessary labour and over six of surplus. An acre of wheat in 1815 gives a rate above 100 per cent, with the surplus shared out as profit, interest, rent and tithes.

Next he takes the twelve-hour day that makes 20 lbs of yarn worth 30 shillings, and cuts the product itself into proportions. Twenty-four shillings is old value, so 16 lbs of the yarn are cotton and spindle in disguise. Only 4 lbs hold the new value of six shillings. Of those, 2 lbs replace the wage and 2 lbs are the owner's surplus. Marx then runs the same sum through time instead of space. On the manufacturer's clock the spinner earns back the cotton in the first eight hours, the tools in the next hour and thirty-six minutes and his wage in the next hour and twelve minutes, and makes the surplus in the last hour and twelve minutes. The English manufacturer uses this reckoning daily. But it breeds what Marx calls barbarian notions in anyone who wants to misunderstand it, because it makes the spinner appear to produce his own cotton, spindles, engine and coal while he spins, and to turn one working day into five.

The famous case comes in 1836, when Nassau Senior is summoned from Oxford to Manchester to be taught political economy by the manufacturers. They elect him their champion against the new Factory Act and the Ten Hours agitation, and he writes it up in a pamphlet. A mill that works 11½ hours a day, he says, earns its whole net profit in the last hour. He lays out £100,000, with £80,000 in the mill and £20,000 in cotton and wages, and brings in £115,000 in goods. In his count, twenty of the twenty-three half-hours merely replace capital and one covers the wear of the machinery. The last two make the profit. Work thirteen hours and profit more than doubles. Cut one hour and it is destroyed, and cut an hour and a half and even the gross profit goes. Marx's reply is to do the sum Senior should have done, with wages on one side and everything else on the other. On the manufacturers' own figures the worker earns his wages in 5¾ hours and the profit in the other 5¾. The yarn of the last hour holds 5¾ hours of work, but 4¾ of those were in the cotton and machinery before he touched them. At thirteen hours the rate rises from 100 to about 126 per cent, not to 200. At ten hours it falls to about 82, which is still very profitable. Marx tells the masters that whenever their last hour strikes in earnest, they should think of the Oxford Professor. In 1848 the Economist's James Wilson raised the same cry against the ten hours' bill. A short section on surplus-produce follows, and it adds that a nation's wealth should be measured by the relative size of its surplus-produce, not by the total produced.

The footnotes show what the cry was used for. Leonard Horner, the factory inspector, wrote to Senior in 1837 that his figures were worth no more than his analysis. In 1855 the inspector Hovell noted that if Senior had been right, every cotton mill in the country would have been losing money since 1850. Dr. Ure, Marx adds dryly, showed that children turned out an hour sooner from the warm and pure moral atmosphere of the factory would lose all hope for their souls through idleness and vice. In 1848 a few flax mills on the borders of Dorset and Somerset got their workpeople to sign a petition against the ten hours' bill, saying that an extra hour of leisure would demoralise the children. The inspectors answered that the air in those mills was so thick with flax dust that nobody could stand ten minutes in the spinning rooms. They called the talk of idleness and vice the purest cant. By then the old claim had grown to cover morals as well as profit, and both, in the masters' telling, would vanish together with this last, this fatal hour.

Amplified Discussion
Why Your Boss Wants You to Think About Gross Revenue Instead of Your Value

Marx discovered something crucial that still applies today: the people who profit most from your work have a vested interest in keeping you confused about basic math. When your manager shows you the company's 'total costs' and 'slim profit margins,' they're doing what those 1860s factory owners did—mixing up replacement costs with value creation to hide how much unpaid work they're extracting from you. Here's the key insight: machines, buildings, and raw materials don't create new value—they just transfer their existing value into the final product. Only human labor creates wealth beyond what existed before. That's why a $2 piece of wood becomes a $50 chair, why raw ingredients become a restaurant meal worth five times their cost, why your research and writing become a report your company charges clients $10,000 for. The difference isn't magic—it's your unpaid labor. Today's gig economy perfected this shell game. Uber talks about 'connecting riders and drivers' while taking 25-40% of each fare. Amazon describes warehouse workers as 'fulfillment associates' while extracting massive value from their physical labor. Healthcare systems claim 'patient care missions' while profiting from nurses working unpaid overtime. The pattern is always the same: obscure the real source of value creation, then capture that value while telling workers they're lucky to participate. When you can do Marx's math—separating what replaces costs from what creates new wealth—you see through the fog and understand exactly how much of your life someone else is claiming.

Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.

AI Discussion
Why it matters

Questioning Margin Warnings

When a boss warns that one small change will wreck the whole business, it helps to know which costs are really in the sum. In 1836 the economist Nassau Senior wrote that a mill's whole net profit came from its last hour, and Marx showed the claim fell apart once wages were counted apart from cotton and machinery. Next time you hear that shorter hours or a pay rise would ruin everything, ask for the wage bill to be listed apart from materials, rent and equipment before you accept the warning.

Lessons

PracticeThis week, when someone says one extra hour is all that keeps the business afloat, ask which costs are in the sum.

Psych reading

Blending Costs to Blur Exploitation

Mixing transferred costs with wages makes exploitation look smaller and reform look economically impossible.

In the mind

Marx documents a propaganda move still common in earnings calls: blend every cost together, then claim any reform would destroy the fragile profit supposedly hiding in one corner of the day or budget.

Workers hear the blended story as inevitability. If all spending looks equally sacred, cutting hours, raising wages, or slowing pace appears economically impossible even when the ratio of surplus to variable capital tells another tale.

Carry a pocket calculator into labour disputes. Separate replacement costs from wages, then compute the rate. Numbers will not solve politics, but they can stop obvious bluffs.

Find the right chapter

Each mood maps to a life skill. Each skill connects to the patterns in classic literature.

😔How do you feel😊

Personalize your match

Optional—life stage, what you need today, and what you're navigating help us pick chapters that fit—not generic lists. You may also freeform using the feeling search below.

Sign in to save your profile

Choices stay on this device until you sign in.

Browse the Full Library
4,582Chapters
118+Books
86Authors