Many who are already proficients still carry habitual imperfections that must be removed before they can arrive at divine union. They not only have these flaws. They have grown so used to them that they no longer even notice them. Progress has not finished the work. It has made the remaining faults invisible. Habit has hidden what still blocks love.
These are people who have already journeyed for some time along the road of virtue. They have done great penances, kept long fasts, and performed many other exercises. Yet they have not perfectly subdued their natural desires, nor raised themselves to the heights of perfection. The resume of practice is real. Desire has still not been fully quieted. Another fast will not, by itself, finish what these unnoticed habits keep in place.
For that reason it becomes necessary that God purge them and make them dark, so that he may bring them into the divine light of the perfect union of love. Saint John is saying darkness is not a demotion for people who have already worked hard. It is how the blind spots get treated. Light comes after God makes them dark, not after they add another exercise. The unnoticed habits are the ones this night is for. They have to be made dark so union can be light.
John identified a pattern that plays out in every workplace today: people who've earned their competence can become prisoners of it. The CNA who's great with patients but resistant to new protocols. The mechanic whose experience makes him dismiss newer diagnostic tools. The retail manager who built her reputation on customer service but struggles to delegate because 'nobody does it right.' This isn't about lazy people or beginners—it's about successful people who've hit a ceiling they can't see. The medieval mystic and the modern worker face identical psychology: we become so invested in our identity as 'someone who's good at this' that we can't admit where we're still learning. Our ego attaches to our track record, making us defensive exactly where we need to stay curious. The factory worker who's been there fifteen years and knows every machine might resist safety updates because accepting them feels like admitting ignorance. But the same humility that built their expertise is what's needed to expand it. The cruel irony is that the confidence required to advance often becomes the pride that prevents advancement. Saint Juan understood that sometimes feeling like you're going backward—questioning what you thought you knew—is actually the first sign you're ready to go deeper.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion