Two months have passed since the news of Austerlitz and the loss of Prince Andrew reached Bald Hills. Letters through the embassy and all the searches have found neither his body nor his name on the list of prisoners. Worst of all is the possibility that people of the place picked him up, and that he may now be recovering or dying among strangers, unable to send word. The gazettes from which the old prince first heard of the defeat stated, as usual briefly, that after brilliant engagements the Russians had had to retreat in perfect order. He understood that the army had been beaten. A week later Kutúzov writes that the son fell before his eyes, a standard in his hand, at the head of a regiment, as a hero worthy of his father and his fatherland. To the regret of Kutúzov and the whole army it is still uncertain whether he is alive. The hope is that he lives, for otherwise he would have been named among officers found on the field, a list sent under flag of truce.
The old prince receives this late, alone in his study. Next morning he walks as usual, silent with steward, gardener, and architect, grim, saying nothing. When Princess Mary comes at the usual hour he is at his lathe and does not look round. "Ah, Princess Mary!" he says in an unnatural voice, throwing down his chisel. The wheel goes on revolving; she will long remember that dying creak. His face is not sad or crushed but angry and working unnaturally. She sees hanging over her the worst in life, irreparable: the death of one she loves. "Father! Andrew!" The ungraceful princess has such charm of sorrow that he turns away with a sob. "Bad news! He's not among the prisoners nor among the killed! Kutúzov writes..." He screams as if to drive her away: "Killed!" She does not faint. Something brightens in her radiant eyes, a supreme joy apart from this world's joys and sorrows overflowing the grief. She forgets fear, draws him down, and puts her arm round his thin neck. "Let us weep together." "Scoundrels! Blackguards! Destroying the army, destroying the men! And why? Go and tell Lise." She weeps in an armchair, seeing Andrew at leave-taking, tender and proud, putting on the little icon. Did he believe? Is he now in eternal peace? The prince will not say how it happened: killed in battle where the best of Russian men were led to destruction. She must tell Lise; he will follow.
When she returns, the little princess is at her embroidery with the inner, happy calm of pregnant women, eyes looking within at something joyful and mysterious. "Mary, give me your hand." She holds it below her waist, downy lip lifted in childlike happiness. "Do you feel it? I am going to love him very much." Mary kneels and hides her face in the dress, weeping. "Sad about Andrew," she says, wiping tears on her sister-in-law's knee. Several times that morning she tries to prepare Lise and only cries. Unobservant as the little princess is, the tears agitate her. Before dinner the old prince comes in with a restless, malign look and goes out without a word. Lise asks if anything has come from Andrew. It is too soon for news; Father is anxious. Mary, radiant eyes firm, has determined not to tell, and has persuaded her father to hide the news until after the confinement, expected within a few days. Each hides grief in a different way. The old prince will not cherish hope: he decides Andrew is killed, sends an official to Austria to seek traces, orders a monument from Moscow for the garden, and tells everybody his son is dead. He tries not to change his life, but he walks less, eats less, sleeps less, and grows weaker every day. Princess Mary hopes. She prays for her brother as living and is always awaiting news of his return.
Tolstoy presents a moral dilemma that plays out in hospitals, living rooms, and workplaces every day: When is withholding devastating news an act of love, and when is it a form of control? The family's decision to hide Andrew's probable death from pregnant Lise seems compassionate - why destroy her joy when the baby needs her calm? But it also strips her of agency. She can't make informed decisions about her future or say goodbye in her own way. This tension between protection and autonomy intensifies in modern life. Families hide cancer diagnoses from elderly grandparents, parents shield children from financial ruin, spouses conceal job losses during pregnancy. Each situation demands weighing someone's right to know against their capacity to cope. The old prince processes grief through rage and planning. Princess Mary finds strength in hope and prayer. Lise lives in blissful ignorance. Tolstoy suggests there's no universal right answer - only the specific needs of specific people at specific moments. But he also shows the cost: someone always pays the emotional price for maintaining these protective silences. The question isn't whether to protect people we love, but how to do it without sacrificing their dignity or our own integrity.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion