The French absorption of Moscow, spreading starwise, only reached the quarter where Pierre was staying by the evening of the second of September. After two days of solitude he was close to insanity, obsessed by one persistent thought, remembering nothing of the past and understanding nothing of the present. He had left home to escape life's tangle and taken refuge in Joseph Alexeevich's sealed study, where Masonic calm used to live. There, memories of Borodino rose: his own insignificance beside the truth and strength of the men he classed as they. When Gerasim roused him, he asked for a peasant's coat and a pistol, meaning to hide his name and join the popular defence. The cabalistic fancy that L'russe Besuhof was destined to limit the Beast still came and went. Then he met the Rostovs, and Natasha said it would be splendid if he remained. After he went to the Three Hills gate and saw that Moscow would not be defended, remaining ceased to be a possibility and became a necessity. He must meet Napoleon and kill him, and either perish or end the misery of Europe.
He knew the German student of 1809 had been shot in Vienna, and the risk excited him. Two feelings held him: the need to sacrifice and suffer with the common calamity, which had already sent him to sleep on a hard sofa and eat Gerasim's food; and that Russian contempt for everything conventional, first tasted at the Sloboda Palace, the joy of renouncing what men guard. What he had already done (the flight, the coat, the pistol, the announcement to the Rostovs) made turning back look contemptible. Coarse food, vodka, dirty linen, and sleepless nights kept his body in the same pitch as his mind. At two in the afternoon, with the French already in the city, he stood rehearsing not the blow so much as his own destruction: it is not I but Providence; take me and execute me.
The study door opened. Makar Alexeevich, usually timid, came in drunk, dressing gown unfastened, face red. They are frightened, he said; I will not surrender. Seeing the pistol on the table he seized it and ran into the corridor. Gerasim and the porter tried to take it from him while he yelled about boarding them and called them Bonaparte. Then the cook burst in with a piercing scream: four horsemen were at the porch. The servants let Makar go. In the silent corridor, several hands knocked at the front door.
Chapter twenty-seven closes Pierre's retreat arc: Borodino memory, Natasha's splendid, assassination rehearsal, Makar's Bonaparte, cook's four horsemen. Andrew should read isolation before captivity chapters ahead. Andrew should hear Makar's Bonaparte as mirror to Pierre's Napoleon obsession. Tolstoy shows how private feeling survives when public language hardens around it. Tolstoy shows how private feeling survives when public language hardens around it.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion