Towards four in the afternoon Murat's troops entered Moscow. Württemberg hussars rode in front; the King of Naples followed with a numerous suite. About the middle of the Arbat, near the Church of the Miraculous Icon of St Nicholas, Murat halted for news of the Kremlin. Remaining Muscovites stared in timid bewilderment at the long-haired commander in feathers and gold, wondering whether he was their Tsar. An interpreter's Polish-sounding Russian baffled an old porter. A French officer reported the citadel gates barricaded, probably an ambush. Murat ordered four light guns forward.
Vespers bells from the Kremlin troubled the French; they took the sound for a call to arms. Infantry ran towards the Kutafyev Gate, where beams and screens had been set. Musket shots came from under the gate. Faces that had been cheerfully serene changed to readiness for a bloody fight in a place that was no longer a Moscow street but a new battlefield. Canister rattled against stone and wood. Crows rose cawing over the walls. A bareheaded man in a peasant's coat appeared in the smoke, musket in hand, and took aim. More fire. When the infantry advanced, three wounded and four dead lay in the gateway. Two men in peasant coats ran away along the wall towards the Znamenka. "Clear that away," said an officer. The French dispatched the wounded and threw the corpses over the parapet so they might not stink. Who the men were, nobody knew.
The French entered, camped in Senate Square, and threw chairs from the Senate House windows for fuel. Other detachments spread along the Moroseyka, Lubyanka, Pokrovka, Vozdvizhenka, Nikolski, and Tverskoy. No householders being found, they lived in the city as in a camp. The army that marched in, tattered and reduced to a third, was still a fighting force until the men dispersed into deserted wealthy houses. Then it became marauders. Five weeks later they would leave not as an army but as a mob clutching loot, like a monkey that will not open its fist in a jug of nuts. Orders forbidding violence and announcing a roll call did nothing. Water spilled on dry ground makes mud; a famished army in a rich abandoned city made fires, looting, and the ruin of both. The French blamed Rostopchin's ferocious patriotism; the Russians blamed French barbarity. Tolstoy says Moscow burned because a wooden town left by its owners, occupied by soldiers who smoke, cook, and light campfires, was bound to burn, with or without arson. It did not remain intact like Berlin or Vienna because its inhabitants had not stayed to welcome the enemy with bread and salt, or bring them the keys.
Chapter twenty-six tracks Murat's entry, nameless Kremlin defenders, marauder transformation, monkey-and-nuts metaphor, and Tolstoy's fire thesis. Andrew should pair this with Rostopchin scapegoating and Pierre's isolation. Andrew should hold structural fire thesis against Rostopchin ferocious patriotism myth. Tolstoy shows how private feeling survives when public language hardens around it. Tolstoy shows how private feeling survives when public language hardens around it.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion