Smith classifies sentimentalist theories into those positing a peculiar moral sense and those deriving approbation from sympathy. Dr. Hutcheson, having excluded self-love and reason, assigned approval to a reflex faculty analogous to sight, by which affections appear virtuous or vicious. Smith grants the ingenuity of the doctrine yet presses consequences Hutcheson acknowledged. Qualities belong to objects of a sense, not to the sense itself; yet we condemn the man who applauds tyrannical cruelty as morally evil in the highest degree, not merely strange. Correct moral sentiment, by contrast, appears laudable.
A fallback treats approbation as a peculiar emotion named a sense of right and wrong. Smith answers that emotions preserve their general character across variations, but approbation of humane tenderness and of daring magnanimity are utterly unlike: we are softened by one and elevated by the other. On his theory this must be so because we sympathize with opposite passions in the agent. The same holds for disapprobation: horror at cruelty is not contempt for meanness.
We also approve or disapprove another's approbation according to whether it coincides with our own sentiments; sympathy, not a new faculty, does that work universally. The term moral sense is recent; conscience signifies consciousness of agreement with duty, not the faculty itself. When we approve a character, Smith argues, sentiments arise from sympathy with motives, with beneficiaries' gratitude, with general rules, and with utility; he challenges anyone to name what remains for a moral sense after these are deducted.
The second class derives approbation from sympathy without inventing a special sense. Smith has argued throughout the work that approval draws on four sources: entering the agent's motives, sharing the gratitude of those he benefits, observing conformity to the general rules by which those sympathies proceed, and perceiving beauty in utility when conduct promotes happiness. No instance shows a moral faculty operating alone, unmixed with sympathy, resentment, rule, or taste for order.
Nature acts with economy; sympathy, already manifest in human life, accounts for effects ascribed to a separate moral power. Hutcheson multiplied reflex senses, including public sense and sense of ridicule, where one mechanism suffices. The depraved approver of cruelty proves that judgment concerns fit between sentiment and object, not mere occurrence of a pleasant feeling in the mind.
Smith distinguishes this sympathy from the utility theory treated in Part IV, which explains pleasure in useful qualities by sympathy with the happiness of those affected. That sympathy resembles approval of a well-contrived machine and differs from entering motives or beneficiaries' gratitude. Moral philosophy describes what passes in the domestic economy of approval; a system wholly disconnected from known mental principles could not impose on readers. Sympathy explains the variety of moral feeling without postulating an occult power that leaves no distinct trace in experience.
Section IV turns to practical rules. Justice alone admits precision like grammar; other virtues resemble critical precepts for sublimity that convey an ideal rather than infallible directions. Ancient moralists described the sentiment underlying each virtue and the ordinary conduct it prompts without unexceptionable rules for every case. Casuists and natural jurists sought exact directions for all circumstances.
Jurisprudence asks what force may exact; casuistry asks what conscience binds beyond compulsion. The highwayman's extorted promise is not enforceable in law yet may trouble the good man who prizes truth; casuists divide, and common sense grants some regard without a rule covering all sums and circumstances. Violating even a foolish promise carries ignominy because fidelity is necessary even toward the worthless.
Casuistry arose from auricular confession: penitents disclosed scruples; confessors collected cases for absolution. Smith charges that casuists attempted in vain to direct by precise rules what belongs to feeling alone. When scrupulosity becomes frivolous or ease becomes licentiousness, no book's decision fits the next variation. Such works teach chicane with conscience and fail to excite the emotions morality should awaken. Ethics and jurisprudence are the useful parts of moral philosophy; the ancient manner of describing sentiments and typical conduct judged better than casuistical exactness.
Smith closes with a distinction governing how moral knowledge should be used. Every system of positive law is an imperfect attempt toward natural jurisprudence. Magistrates enforce justice because men will not submit to mutual injury; written rules aim to coincide with natural equity, though interest, barbarism, and bad courts ensure divergence. Cicero and Aristotle treated justice among the virtues generally; Grotius offered the most complete early attempt at principles running through the laws of nations.
Casuistry should be rejected not because circumstances do not matter, but because propriety in non-juridical virtues cannot be codified without falsifying the role of sentiment. The good man needs cultivated perception of what friendship, modesty, and veracity feel like from within, and acquaintance with how a humane person ordinarily acts. That is ethics: imprecise like criticism, yet useful and capable of impressing youth when vividly delivered.
Practical wisdom is neither slavish rule-following nor reliance on an innate moral sense. It is habituation of the impartial spectator, trained by examples, maxims induced from experience, and sympathy with those affected by our conduct. Juridical exactness belongs to justice; beyond that, moral life remains an art of fit feeling and conduct. Sentiment grounds approbation; sympathy explains it; reason generalizes it; casuistry misapplies it.
Smith identified something we still struggle with: our desperate desire to reduce moral complexity to simple rules. We see this everywhere - zero-tolerance policies in schools that punish victims alongside bullies, workplace harassment training that focuses on legal compliance rather than building respectful cultures, parenting advice that promises foolproof techniques for every situation. The appeal is obvious. Rules eliminate uncertainty, reduce liability, and make us feel we're 'doing the right thing' without the messy work of actually understanding people. But Smith understood what we keep forgetting: morality isn't a multiple-choice test with predetermined answers. It's an ongoing practice of trying to understand how our actions affect others. The medieval casuists he criticized tried to create a moral GPS system - input your dilemma, get your answer. Modern institutions do the same thing with policies, procedures, and compliance training. But real ethical behavior requires what Smith called 'moral sentiments' - the capacity to imagine ourselves in others' shoes and respond with both principle and compassion. This doesn't mean abandoning all rules or standards. It means recognizing that rules should support moral judgment, not replace it. The goal isn't perfect adherence to a system but developing the wisdom to navigate imperfect situations with genuine care for others.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion