Past five o'clock Marguerite sends Louise to bed, opens the windows, and looks down on the terrace she has just left. Armand still matters, yet the sharper ache is Percy's coldness. She realises she has never stopped loving him, and that his empty laugh has always felt like a mask over something he hides from the world, most of all from her. She means to win that obstinate heart back. Time slips. A noise of footsteps and hushed voices wakes her. On the doorstep lies a letter in his large, businesslike hand. Unforeseen circumstance, he writes, forces him north at once. He will miss her water-party. He remains her humble, obedient servant. She reads it again and again. He owns land in the North and has gone there before, yet nothing waited for him between five and six in the morning. She flies downstairs in a wrap, hair loose, bruising her hands on the heavy bolts. In the yard a groom holds Sultan, saddled. Percy appears, changed from ball dress into fine cloth and top-boots. A slight frown meets her.
She asks whither. Urgent unexpected business in the North, he drawls. She says there were no letters before the opera and nothing after the ball. There is no mystery, he answers. My business has to do with Armand. Now, have I your leave to depart? She asks if he will run danger. Nay, he has influence and means to use it before it is too late. She stretches out both hands and offers her life in exchange. He bows, kisses her hand; she feels the burning kiss and takes hope. He will always remember, he says, that she has honoured him by commanding his services. The words are cold. This time they do not chill her. She reads the heart under the mask.
He gallops out. She waves, then goes back to bed like a tired child. She no longer fears Chauvelin. Lord Fancourt and Chauvelin both said nobody was in the dining-room at one except the Frenchman and Percy. Percy! She might have asked him. She has no fear that the unknown hero will fall. Armand is still in danger, yet the man who just rode away cannot fail. She draws the curtains against the sun and sleeps. Two facts stay side by side: her heart is at peace, and his road is not the North.
Marguerite's revelation about Percy illuminates a painful truth about modern relationships: we often choose comfortable misunderstanding over difficult recognition. She spent months living with a version of Percy she created in her own mind rather than seeing the man actually beside her. This wasn't mere oversight - it was protective. Seeing Percy's depth would have required confronting her own role in their distance, admitting her assumptions were wrong, and risking vulnerability. The 'foolish fop' was easier to dismiss than a wounded hero. This pattern dominates contemporary relationships at every level. The parent who sees their struggling teenager as 'just being dramatic' instead of genuinely overwhelmed. The spouse who dismisses their partner's quiet contributions as 'not enough ambition' when they're actually choosing family stability over career risk. The supervisor who labels the shy employee as 'lacking leadership potential' while missing their behind-the-scenes problem-solving. We create simplified versions of people to manage our own discomfort with complexity, uncertainty, or guilt. But this protective blindness costs us authentic connection. When we reduce someone to a story that serves our emotional needs, we lose access to who they actually are. The chapter suggests that true intimacy requires the courage to see clearly, even when that seeing demands we update our understanding and admit we were wrong.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion