LIVE
OCD← Home
The Prince cover
1532
The Prince
Niccolò Machiavelli · Why Flattery Is the Most Dangerous Threat Any Leader Will Ever Face
Chapter 23
Ch. 22
Reading
Ch. 23
Ch. 24
Loading audio...
0:000:00

Flatterers fill every court because men are self-complimented and easily deceived about their own affairs. Princes can barely escape this pest. If you try to guard against flattery by letting everyone speak plain truth, you lose respect. Machiavelli's answer is a third course between open door and isolation.

Choose wise men and give only them liberty to tell the truth, and only on the subjects you raise. Question them on everything, listen to their opinions, then decide for yourself. Treat these councillors so that the more freely they speak, the more they are preferred. Outside that circle, listen to no one, execute what you resolved, and hold steady. Otherwise flatterers overturn you or shifting opinions make you contemptible.

Maximilian, the present emperor, shows the opposite failure. Fra Luca, his man of affairs, said he consulted no one yet never got his own way. He kept designs secret and took no counsel, but when actions became visible his courtiers obstructed them and he, being pliant, changed course daily. No one knew what he intended or could rely on his word.

A prince should take counsel when he wishes, not when others wish, and should discourage unsolicited advice. He must inquire constantly and listen patiently, then show anger when he learns someone withheld truth. Do not imagine a prince looks wise only because of good advisers. An unwise prince never takes good advice unless he hands everything to one prudent man, and even then the governor will soon seize the state. Many advisers without judgment produce divided counsel and hidden self interest. Men stay honest only under constraint. Good counsels come from the prince's wisdom, not the other way around.

Amplified Discussion
The Flattery Trap

Chapter 23 is Machiavelli on the seduction of yes men. Courts are full of flatterers because leaders like their own stories and hate hearing otherwise. Open the door to universal bluntness and respect falls; close it completely and flattery wins by default.

His third course is structured honesty. A few wise councillors may speak truth, but only when asked and only on the topics the prince raises. Reward frankness inside that circle, ignore everyone else, and hold to the decision once made. Maximilian shows the opposite trap: secretive, unconsulted, pliant, reversing himself daily until no one can rely on him.

The closing denies the fantasy that good advisers substitute for judgment. An unwise prince either ignores counsel or surrenders to one prudent man who will soon take the state. Many voices without control produce self interested fragments. Constraint keeps men honest. The prince's wisdom produces good counsel, not the reverse.

In modern terms: When a leader either invites everyone to speak freely or listens to no one, flatterers and confusion fill the gap and respect collapses either way

Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.

AI Discussion
Why it matters

Getting Honest Counsel Without Losing Authority

Flattery thrives because leaders want to feel right, yet letting everyone speak plain truth openly can erode respect as quickly as listening to no one does. Machiavelli chooses a few wise councillors who may speak truth only when asked, while Fra Luca says Maximilian consulted no one and never got his own way. Inquire constantly, listen patiently, punish withheld truth, and remember that good counsel comes from your judgment, not the reverse.

Lessons

PracticeName three people allowed to challenge you on one live decision, ask each a direct question this week, decide, and hold the resolution unless new facts truly change the stakes.

Psych reading

The Flattery Trap

When a leader either invites everyone to speak freely or listens to no one, flatterers and confusion fill the gap and respect collapses either way

In the mind

Chapter 23 is Machiavelli on the seduction of yes men. Courts are full of flatterers because leaders like their own stories and hate hearing otherwise. Open the door to universal bluntness and respect falls; close it completely and flattery wins by default.

His third course is structured honesty. A few wise councillors may speak truth, but only when asked and only on the topics the prince raises. Reward frankness inside that circle, ignore everyone else, and hold to the decision once made. Maximilian shows the opposite trap: secretive, unconsulted, pliant, reversing himself daily until no one can rely on him.

The closing denies the fantasy that good advisers substitute for judgment. An unwise prince either ignores counsel or surrenders to one prudent man who will soon take the state. Many voices without control produce self interested fragments. Constraint keeps men honest. The prince's wisdom produces good counsel, not the reverse.

Find the right chapter

Each mood maps to a life skill. Each skill connects to the patterns in classic literature.

😔How do you feel😊

Personalize your match

Optional—life stage, what you need today, and what you're navigating help us pick chapters that fit—not generic lists. You may also freeform using the feeling search below.

Sign in to save your profile

Choices stay on this device until you sign in.

Browse the Full Library
4,582Chapters
118+Books
86Authors