A prince is judged by the people around him. The first opinion others form of his understanding comes from observing whether his servants are capable and faithful. When they are, he looks wise because he knew how to recognize talent and keep it loyal. When they are not, the fault usually began in the choice itself.
Machiavelli cites Pandolfo Petrucci of Siena and his secretary Antonio da Venafro. There are three kinds of mind: one that comprehends by itself, one that appreciates what others comprehend, and one that does neither. The first is most excellent, the second good, the third useless. A prince who lacks the first rank can still succeed in the second if he has judgment enough to hear good and bad advice, praise the good, correct the bad, and keep a servant from deceiving him.
The test of a servant never fails: watch whether he thinks more of his own interests than yours and seeks his own profit in everything. A man who holds another's state in his hands must never think of himself but always of his prince and must not chase matters where the prince has no stake. To keep such a man honest, the prince should honour him, enrich him, share honours and cares, and at the same time show that he cannot stand alone, so that honours do not breed ambition, riches do not breed greed, and shared burdens do not make him dread a fall. When prince and servant are disposed this way, they can trust each other. When they are not, disaster follows for one or both.
Chapter 22 is Machiavelli on the inner circle as a mirror of judgment. Observers decide whether a prince is wise by looking at his servants. Pandolfo Petrucci earned credit for keeping Antonio da Venafro because even a prince in the second rank of intellect can govern well if he can recognize good and bad counsel and keep a servant honest.
The middle is the self interest test. Any counselor who thinks first of his own profit cannot be trusted with another's state. The servant must live inside the prince's concerns, not chase private advantage in the master's affairs.
The closing balances reward and restraint. Honour, wealth, and shared cares keep a good servant loyal, but the prince must also show that the servant cannot stand alone, so honours do not swell into ambition and riches do not become a hunger for more. When both sides accept this bargain, trust holds. When either side breaks it, disaster follows.
In modern terms: When someone with power over your affairs consistently prioritizes their own gain, they will never be trustworthy no matter how competent they appear
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion