Machiavelli closes his survey of principality types with ecclesiastical states. They are hard to acquire but easy to hold because ancient religious ordinances sustain them no matter how the prince lives. Such rulers alone have states they do not defend and subjects they do not rule, yet remain secure. Machiavelli says discussing their divine support would be presumptuous, then answers a practical question anyway: how did the papacy become a temporal power kings fear?
Before Charles VIII entered Italy, the peninsula was divided among the Pope, Venice, Naples, Milan, and Florence. Italian powers wanted no foreign armies and no neighbour's expansion. They checked Venice by union and kept the papacy weak by playing Rome's barons, the Orsini and Colonnesi factions, against each other under the pope's eyes. Even a courageous pope like Sixtus could not escape that trap, and a pope's short life made it nearly impossible to destroy a faction before another rose.
Alexander VI showed what money and arms could do. Through Cesare Borgia and the French entry he executed the campaigns Machiavelli described earlier. He meant to aggrandize his son, not the Church, yet after Alexander's death and Borgia's ruin the Church inherited the gains.
Julius II found the papacy strong, with the Romagna, broken barons, and new methods of raising money. He took Bologna, ruined Venice, and drove the French from Italy, always strengthening the Church rather than a private heir. He kept the Orsini and Colonnesi in check by terrifying them with papal greatness and refusing to let factions have their own cardinals, since cardinals stir baronial disorder. Leo X therefore inherited the most powerful pontificate yet.
Chapter 11 begins with a paradox. Ecclesiastical principalities are sustained by religious ordinances so strong that princes may hold them without the virtue or force Machiavelli demands elsewhere. Machiavelli almost stops there, treating such states as maintained by powers beyond human analysis, then turns historian to explain a more worldly puzzle: how the papacy became a temporal force that could frighten France and break Venice.
The middle reconstructs Italy before Charles VIII. The Pope was contained because Orsini and Colonnesi barons, armed under the pontiff's nose, kept the office politically weak. Short papal reigns made faction-breaking nearly impossible even for popes as bold as Sixtus. Alexander VI changed the equation by combining money, French entry, and Cesare Borgia's campaigns. His aim was Borgia's aggrandizement, yet when the duke fell the Church kept the territorial and financial machinery he had built.
Julius II inherits that strength and uses it openly for the institution: Bologna, Venice, the French expulsion, new revenue methods, and tighter control of Roman factions by denying them faction cardinals. Leo X arrives at the peak. Machiavelli's lesson is double: ecclesiastical power can look untouchable because of sacred legitimacy, but the modern papal empire he describes was built through arms, money, and faction management like any other state.
In modern terms: Ecclesiastical states rest on ancient legitimacy, but the papacy's modern temporal power was forged through arms, revenue, and faction control until the institution outlived its private builders
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion