Machiavelli asks how to measure a principality's strength: can the prince, in need, support himself with his own resources, or must he always depend on others?
He divides rulers into two kinds. Those with enough men or money to raise an army and fight in the open field can stand on their own. Those who cannot meet the enemy outside must shelter behind walls. The first case belongs to earlier chapters. For the second, Machiavelli offers defensive doctrine: provision and fortify your towns, and do not on any account try to defend the open country.
A well-fortified city whose prince has governed his subjects as advised elsewhere will not be attacked lightly. Men avoid enterprises where difficulty is visible. The German free cities show the model: little surrounding territory, obedience to the emperor only when it suits them, strong ditches and walls, artillery, public depots stocked for a year's eating, drinking, and firing, work for the people, military exercises in repute, and ordinances to uphold the whole system. A prince with a strong city who has not made himself odious may never be attacked, or an attacker may withdraw in disgrace, especially because keeping an army in the field for a whole year is nearly impossible in this changeable world.
Skeptics say subjects with property outside the walls will turn on the prince when the enemy burns the countryside. Machiavelli answers that a powerful prince alternates hope and fear of the enemy's cruelty and restrains the boldest subjects. The enemy will burn the country on arrival while spirits are still hot for defense, so the prince should not hesitate to sacrifice open land. Once damage is done, subjects bind themselves to the prince because he now appears under obligation to them after their houses were ruined in his defense. Men are bound as much by benefits they confer as by those they receive.
Chapter 10 is Machiavelli's stress test for any principality: can the ruler support himself, or does he always need help? The opening split is blunt. Princes with men and money enough to fight in the field belong to the strong category already discussed. Princes who cannot meet an enemy outdoors must accept a different strategy.
The middle turns to engineering survival behind walls. Fortify towns, stock provisions, and do not waste force defending open country. Machiavelli points to the German free cities as proof that small territory can still mean real independence when ditches, walls, artillery, and a year's supplies make assault look tedious. Keep the people employed, trained, and governed well enough that the prince is not hated.
The closing handles the psychological objection. Enemies burn the countryside early; subjects with outside property may waver. Machiavelli tells the prince to manage hope, fear, and bold subjects, and he adds a darker loyalty mechanism: once citizens lose houses and goods in the prince's defense, they bind themselves to him because they have conferred benefits on him, not only received them. Strength is therefore not just walls and grain but timing, morale, and the politics of shared loss.
In modern terms: A principality's true strength is whether it can support itself in crisis; if not, it must fortify, stock, sacrifice open ground, and keep subjects loyal through governance and shared sacrifice
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion