LIVE
OCD← Home
The Essays of Montaigne cover
1580
The Essays of Montaigne
Michel de Montaigne · Virtue Beyond Good Nature
Chapter 68
Ch. 67
Reading
Ch. 68
Ch. 69
Loading audio...
0:000:00

Montaigne fancies virtue to be something more noble than good nature and the mere propension to goodness we are born with. Well-disposed souls may wear the same face as virtue, yet the word imports something more active than being gently drawn to reason by a happy disposition. The man who, by natural sweetness, despises injuries received does a fine thing. The man who is nettled to the quick, then fortifies himself with reason against revenge and, after a great conflict, masters his own passion, does a great deal more. One action might be called goodness, the other virtue: the very name of virtue presupposes difficulty and an opponent. That is why we call God good, mighty, liberal and just, but not virtuous, since all His operations are natural and without endeavour. Metellus, alone of the Roman senators, withstands Saturninus's unjust law, incurs the capital penalty, and tells those who lead him to execution that to do well where there is no danger is a common thing, but to do well where there is danger is the proper office of a man of virtue. Virtue, Montaigne says, refuses facility for a companion.

Then the rule threatens to break. By this test the soul of Socrates would have little recommendation, for Montaigne cannot conceive in that person the least motion of a vicious inclination. If virtue cannot shine without contrary appetites, must she borrow her honour from vice? Cato tearing out his own bowels does not look like a man merely keeping the Stoic rules: there was a pleasure in so noble an action, and perhaps even an obligation to fortune for putting him on so brave a trial. Socrates in prison shows not only firmness but a frolic cheerfulness: when the irons come off he scratches his leg with pleasure. In both men virtue has turned to a complexion. Montaigne then ranks three sorts: to hinder the birth of temptations; to be surprised by passion and still stand firm; and to be simply endowed with a facile nature disaffected to vice. The third renders a man innocent but not virtuous, so near to cowardice that goodness and innocence have in some sort grown into contempt. An Italian lord in his presence ranked nations by how soon they smelled danger: Italians provide for safety before they have discovered the peril; French and Spaniards must see and feel it; Germans and Swiss do not look about them even when blows fall about their ears. When we judge a particular action, we are to consider the circumstances and the whole man.

To instance in himself, friends have called prudence in him what was merely fortune. He has not arrived at the first degree, where virtue is habit, and of the second he has made no great proofs. His virtue is a virtue, or rather an innocence, casual and accidental, owed to fortune, a good father, and an instinct he brought from his nurse. Aristippus, offered three beautiful women by Dionysius, said he would choose them all, then sent them home untouched. Epicurus lived on biscuit and water and asked only a little cheese against a feast. Amongst other vices Montaigne mortally hates cruelty, as the extreme of all vices. He cannot see a chicken's neck pulled off without trouble, nor endure the cry of a hare in his dog's teeth, though the chase is a violent pleasure. Someone praising Julius Caesar's clemency notes that he had pirates strangled before they were crucified, and punished a poisoning secretary with mere death. Even in justice, all that exceeds a simple death appears to Montaigne pure cruelty. A soldier, shut in a tower, sees carpenters raise a scaffold, stabs himself thrice with a rusty cart-nail, then hears he was only condemned to be beheaded, takes the wine he had refused, and thanks his judges for an unhoped-for mildness.

At Rome he happens on the execution of Catena, a notorious robber: the crowd watches the strangling without emotion, then lends every blow of the quartering a doleful cry. He lives in civil wars that furnish souls who, without hatred and without profit, hack limbs only to enjoy the spectacle of a man dying in anguish. He cannot without grief see an innocent beast pursued. The stag that surrenders in tears is an unpleasing sight, and he hardly ever takes a beast alive that he does not turn out again. Those natures sanguinary towards beasts discover a proneness to cruelty; Rome went from the slaughter of animals to the slaughter of men. Nature herself may have imprinted in man an instinct to inhumanity, yet there is a general duty of humanity not only to beasts but even to trees and plants. He cannot refuse to play with his dog when the dog most unseasonably importunes him. Xantippus inters his dog on a sea eminence that still bears the name, and Plutarch had a scruple about selling, for a small profit, an ox long in his service. The easy descending way is still open. What looks like goodness may be only a mild complexion. What looks like hardness may be only habit.

Amplified Discussion
When Being Right Makes You Wrong

Montaigne wrote this during the French Wars of Religion, when Catholics and Protestants were literally killing each other over who had the 'right' interpretation of God. Each side was absolutely certain they possessed the truth. Sound familiar? Today we see the same pattern everywhere—political tribes, workplace conflicts, family arguments. The more certain someone becomes about their position, the less they can actually hear opposing views. What Montaigne discovered is that this certainty isn't strength—it's intellectual weakness disguised as confidence. Think about your own workplace. The manager who 'knows' exactly how things should be done often misses obvious problems. The coworker who's certain about office politics usually gets blindsided. The parent who 'knows' what's best for their adult child damages the relationship. Montaigne isn't arguing for wishy-washy relativism where nothing matters. He's showing us that real intelligence means holding our beliefs lightly enough to update them when reality provides new information. The strongest position is often: 'I could be wrong about this.' That's not weakness—that's wisdom. It takes more courage to question yourself than to defend yourself.

Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.

AI Discussion
Why it matters

Credit Only the Fought Kindness

Kindness that never had to fight an appetite is easy to wear as a badge. Montaigne says the man who, nettled to the quick by an offence, fortifies himself with reason against revenge and, after a great conflict, masters his own passion, does a great deal more than the man whose natural sweetness simply despises injuries. Before you credit yourself for a kindness this week, write whether you had to fight an appetite to do it, or whether nothing in you wanted the harm in the first place.

Lessons

PracticeBefore you credit yourself for a kindness this week, write whether you had to fight an appetite to do it, or whether nothing in you wanted the harm in the first place.

Psych reading

Credit for Unfought Goodness

A person takes credit for not doing harm they never wanted to do, then treats a mild temperament as a moral achievement.

In the mind

You can wear a week without cruelty as proof of character, then never notice that nothing in you wanted the harm in the first place. The pattern is unfought goodness: ease is mistaken for virtue, and a natural horror of blood is mistaken for a victory over appetite. At work this is the colleague praised as kind because conflict never tempts them, while the person who swallows revenge and still stays fair gets no credit. Montaigne starts by separating virtue from good nature, tests the rule on Socrates and Cato until virtue becomes complexion, then confesses his own innocence is accidental. He cannot watch a chicken's neck or a hare in the dog's teeth. A prisoner stabs himself with a rusty nail at the sight of a scaffold. Catena's crowd cries only when the dead body is quartered. The stag's tears send him to turn the beast loose. Navigation means asking, before you claim a moral win, whether you had an opponent at all.

Find the right chapter

Each mood maps to a life skill. Each skill connects to the patterns in classic literature.

😔How do you feel😊

Personalize your match

Optional—life stage, what you need today, and what you're navigating help us pick chapters that fit—not generic lists. You may also freeform using the feeling search below.

Sign in to save your profile

Choices stay on this device until you sign in.

Browse the Full Library
4,582Chapters
118+Books
86Authors