LIVE
OCD← Home
The Essays of Montaigne cover
1580
The Essays of Montaigne
Michel de Montaigne · How to Read and Learn from Books
Chapter 67
Ch. 66
Reading
Ch. 67
Ch. 68
Loading audio...
0:000:00

Montaigne opens that he often speaks of things better handled by masters of the trade. What the reader has here is purely an essay of his natural parts, not those acquired. Whoever catches him tripping in ignorance will not get the better of him, for he will not become responsible to another for writings he is not satisfied with himself. If he is a man of some reading, he is a man of no retention. He weighs borrowings rather than numbering them, and when he transplants reasons into his own soil he conceals the author, so precipitate censors will give Plutarch a fillip on his nose and rail against Seneca when they think they rail at him. He must shelter his own weakness under those great reputations. He could wish a more perfect knowledge of things, but he will not buy it so dear as it costs. In books he seeks only honest diversion, or the science that treats of the knowledge of himself and instructs him how to die and how to live well. After a charge or two he gives a hard page over. If one book does not please him, he takes another.

Among books simply pleasant he still allows Boccaccio, Rabelais, and Johannes Secundus; Amadis never arrested even his childhood, and Ariosto and Ovid no longer tickle this old heavy soul. When he is disgusted with Plato's Axiochus, his judgment would rather err with the tutors of antiquity than oppose them. He sets Virgil's Georgics first among poems. Modern comic writers load three or four plots because they distrust their own strength. The Aeneid flies and keeps its point; Orlando Furioso hops from tale to tale. For profit mixed with pleasure he names Plutarch, now in French, and Seneca: loose pieces he can put down at will. Cicero's moral works smother the marrow in prefaces. After an hour Montaigne tries to recollect juice and finds wind. Wanting to become more wise, not more learned or eloquent, he asks a writer to begin with the main proposition and charge the redoubt. He comes already prepared from his chamber. He needs no Oyez, no sauce; he eats the meat raw.

He will even censure Plato's long interlocutions as dull, too much stifling the matter. He chooses books that use sciences, not such as only lead to them, and reads the Epistles to Atticus for private humours, because public writings show parts, not manners. He would rather know the conference in Brutus's tent the night before a battle than the next day's harangue. Of Cicero, learning excepted, he finds no great natural excellence, and the younger Cicero has Cestius whipped at table for slighting the father's eloquence. Historians are then his right ball. Those who write lives, insisting more upon counsels than events, are the most proper, and Plutarch is the man for him. Caesar deserves study for himself and for his language, except that he palliates a pestilent ambition and speaks too sparingly of his own share. Honest Froissart collects without discrimination, confesses an error where the finger is laid, and leaves the judgment of truth to the reader.

The more excellent historians may regulate belief, but that privilege belongs to very few. The middle sort spoil all: they chew the meat, wrest the narrative to their bias, and hide a private action that would instruct. Latter-age writers are culled for well-speaking and stitch street reports. The only good histories are those written by men who held command. Asinius Pollio found even Caesar misreporting a battle from lieutenants. Montaigne's memory is so extreme that he has taken scribbled books again as new, so he notes at the end of every book he will not reread the time he made an end, and the judgment he had made of it. In Guicciardini he finds a diligent actor who never attributes any motive to virtue, and therefore suspects the historian's own taste was vicious. The Memoirs of Monsieur du Bellay are rather an apology for King Francis against Charles V than history: Montmorency and Biron are omitted, and the very name of Madame d'Estampes is not to be found. Secret actions an historian may conceal, but to pass over in silence what all the world knows is an inexcusable defect. Whoever wants a perfect knowledge of that reign must still seek it elsewhere.

Amplified Discussion
The Intelligence Performance vs. Authentic Learning

Montaigne lived in an era when humanist scholars were expected to master everything from Latin poetry to natural philosophy, yet he openly admitted his terrible memory and impatience with difficult texts. Today, we face similar pressure to perform intelligence—whether it's keeping up with industry jargon, pretending to understand complex policies at work, or nodding along in conversations about topics that bore us senseless. Montaigne's radical move was treating his limitations as information rather than failures. His poor memory led him to take detailed notes, creating a personal knowledge system that worked better than trying to memorise everything. His impatience with boring texts led him to focus on writers who engaged him, resulting in deeper understanding than if he'd forced himself through everything. This wasn't anti-intellectual—it was intelligently selective. The pattern appears everywhere: the mechanic who admits when a problem is beyond their expertise learns faster than one who fakes knowledge; the parent who says 'let's look that up together' teaches better research skills than one who bluffs answers; the employee who focuses on projects that genuinely interest them often becomes the go-to expert in those areas. Montaigne suggests that authentic learning—admitting what you don't know, focusing on what genuinely engages you, building systems around your actual capabilities—produces better results than performing the intelligence others expect.

Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.

AI Discussion
Why it matters

Write the End Judgment

You can finish a long report and still be unable to say, in one sentence, what you now think, or what the writer left out. Montaigne's memory is so weak that he retakes scribbled books as new, so he notes at the end of each book he will not reread the time and the judgment, and on the Du Bellay memoirs he writes that the name of Madame d'Estampes is not to be found. When you finish one book or briefing this week, write the date and one judgment, and name one public fact the record passed over.

Lessons

PracticeWhen you finish one book or briefing this week, write the date and one judgment, and name one public fact the record passed over.

Psych reading

The Borrowed Cover

A person hides thin thinking under a famous name, or lets someone else chew the facts until only a bias remains.

In the mind

A thin thought can look finished once a famous name is stapled to it, and a long file can look complete once a fluent writer has chewed it into a shape that suits the house. The habit shows up in meetings, reviews, and official write-ups: people rent authority, skip the private hour where a decision was actually made, and pass over the public fact everyone in the room already knows. The mind stays thin while the shelf, the citation list, and the polished recap look full. Montaigne's own fix is small and bodily. Memory so weak that marked books come back as new, he writes the date and his judgment on the last page of a volume he will not open again, so the next meeting with that author is not a bluff. Navigation means doing the same before you repeat a briefing: weigh the loan, say in plain words what you now do differently, and name the gap the fluent version left out. When you can name this pattern, predict where it leads, and adjust before you commit, you have a map for the next time the same pressure appears.

Find the right chapter

Each mood maps to a life skill. Each skill connects to the patterns in classic literature.

😔How do you feel😊

Personalize your match

Optional—life stage, what you need today, and what you're navigating help us pick chapters that fit—not generic lists. You may also freeform using the feeling search below.

Sign in to save your profile

Choices stay on this device until you sign in.

Browse the Full Library
4,582Chapters
118+Books
86Authors