LIVE
OCD← Home
The Essays of Montaigne cover
1580
The Essays of Montaigne
Michel de Montaigne · The True Value of Recognition
Chapter 64
Ch. 63
Reading
Ch. 64
Ch. 65
Loading audio...
0:000:00

Writers of the life of Augustus Caesar note that he was wonderfully liberal of gifts to men of merit, yet as sparing with the true recompenses of honour, though his uncle had already given him all the military honours before he had ever been in the field. Most governments invent vain and in themselves valueless distinctions to honour virtue: crowns of laurel, oak, and myrtle; a particular fashion of garment; the privilege to ride in a coach in the city, or at night with a torch; a peculiar place in public assemblies; extra names, titles, and coats of arms.

France and its neighbours institute orders of knighthood for the same end, and men of quality have always been more jealous of such honours than of rewards with gain in them. Mix riches with the honour and the mixture debases it. The Order of Saint Michael long held repute because it had no communication with any other commodity. Gentry pretended to it with more desire than to any office. Money pays a servant, a courier, dancing, vaulting, even flattery and pimping. Virtue less willingly receives that common payment. Augustus had reason to be more sparing of honour than of gifts, because honour derives its principal essence from rarity, and so does virtue. No one commends a citizen of Sparta for valour when valour is the universal virtue of the nation. There is no recompense that becomes virtue once it has passed into a custom.

Seeing that these remunerations have no value but that few people enjoy them, to be liberal of them is to bring them down to nothing. Even if more men now merit the order, the honour should not be made cheap. Military valour spreads easily. The civil wars have already made it common. The old recompense regarded not a valiant soldier but a great captain, for the arts of soldiery and generalship are not the same. Better to fall short and give it to no one than to lose, as France has lately done, the fruit of so profitable an invention. Men of spirit will not deign to share what is common with many. Those who have least merited it now make the greater show of disdaining it. To abolish the old order and suddenly create a like institution in so sick a time is to give the new one the same contempt from birth. The rules would need extreme restriction, and this tumultuous season cannot hold such a curb. French court style uses a man of high worth and a good man to mean a valiant man, as Rome drew virtue from force. The same nation calls a good woman only a chaste woman, as if that one duty compounded for the rest.

Amplified Discussion
The Participation Trophy Problem

Montaigne identified a psychological trap that dominates modern life: our well-intentioned attempts to make people feel valued often destroy the very value we're trying to create. When Augustus Caesar hoarded medals while freely giving money, he understood something we've forgotten—scarcity creates meaning. Today we see this pattern everywhere. Schools give participation trophies that kids throw away because they know they didn't earn them. Workplaces create 'Employee of the Month' programs where everyone eventually wins, making the recognition meaningless. Social media likes feel empty because they're infinite. Even job titles get inflated until everyone's a 'senior director' of something. The cruel irony is that our desire to make everyone feel special ensures that no one feels special. We've confused equality of opportunity with equality of recognition. Montaigne suggests it's better to give no recognition at all than to cheapen it through inflation. This creates a difficult question for parents, managers, and teachers: How do we encourage people without devaluing encouragement itself? The answer might lie in recognising the process rather than just participation—praising genuine effort, specific improvement, or particular skills rather than just showing up. When we can distinguish between earned recognition and manufactured praise, we protect the power of both to actually motivate and acknowledge real achievement.

Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.

AI Discussion
Why it matters

Withhold the Cheap Badge

A title that already sits on every desk in the room has stopped doing the work a title is for. Writers of Augustus's life note that he was wonderfully liberal of gifts yet sparing with true recompenses of honour, and Montaigne says to be liberal of those marks is to bring them down to nothing. Before you hand out another badge this week, count how many people already hold the last one, and withhold the new one if rarity is what gave it meaning.

Lessons

PracticeBefore you hand out another badge this week, count how many people already hold the last one, and withhold the new one if rarity is what gave it meaning.

Psych reading

Spending the Scarce Mark

A person uses a rare honour as if it were ordinary wages, then wonders why the mark no longer moves anyone.

In the mind

A rare honour is often spent as if it were ordinary wages, then the room wonders why the mark no longer moves anyone. Montaigne moves from Augustus, liberal with gifts and sparing with honour, through crowns of laurel and the Order of Saint Michael, to a new institution born into the same contempt. The mechanism is treating symbolic scarcity as if it were cash you can pour. A weekly plaque, a title on every desk, or a grade that everyone already holds works the same way. Navigation means counting who already carries the last mark, and withholding the next one when rarity is still the meaning. When you can name this pattern, predict where it leads, and adjust before you commit, you have a map for the next time the same pressure appears.

Find the right chapter

Each mood maps to a life skill. Each skill connects to the patterns in classic literature.

😔How do you feel😊

Personalize your match

Optional—life stage, what you need today, and what you're navigating help us pick chapters that fit—not generic lists. You may also freeform using the feeling search below.

Sign in to save your profile

Choices stay on this device until you sign in.

Browse the Full Library
4,582Chapters
118+Books
86Authors