LIVE
OCD← Home
The Essays of Montaigne cover
1580
The Essays of Montaigne
Michel de Montaigne · Practice Makes Perfect
Chapter 63
Ch. 62
Reading
Ch. 63
Ch. 64
Loading audio...
0:000:00

Montaigne says argument and instruction cannot lead a person to action unless experience also forms the soul for the course it is designed. Philosophers who wanted a greater excellence would not wait for fortune in retirement. They sallied out to meet her: some abandoned riches, some sought labour and austerity, some even deprived themselves of sight or generation so pleasure would not soften them. Death is the one work practice cannot assist. Custom may fortify a man against pain, shame, and necessity, but death can be tried only once, and all arrive as apprentices. Julius Canus, condemned by Caligula, keeps his mind settled at the executioner's stroke to see whether the soul has any sentiment at the separation, so he may come again if he can and tell his friends. Montaigne cannot overtake death, but he can approach the avenues. Sleep resembles it; a swoon comes nearer still. The approaches are what we fear, and those can fall within experience.

He has spent much of his life in sprightly health, and sickness looked formidable until he felt it and found the attacks faint beside the fear. A warm room in a storm makes him pity those in the fields; once he is out himself, he does not wish to be elsewhere. During the civil wars, about a league from his house, a lusty fellow on a strong German horse, playing the brave, thunders into Montaigne's easy but weak mount and turns them both over, heels in the air. Companions conclude him dead and carry him home. After more than two hours he throws off a bucket of clotted blood, and his first sentiments are nearer death than life. He shuts his eyes to help thrust life out, and finds in that languishing the sweetness of gliding into slumber. He has always believed, contrary to La Boetie, that the dying we pity, groaning and twitching, have body and soul benumbed, and are not much to be pitied.

In the swoon his nails rip at his doublet and his hands go to his oppressed stomach without a commission from reason. Near the house he even orders a horse for his wife on the hilly road, yet he knows not what he said or did. Put to bed, he refuses remedies, certain he is mortally wounded in the head, and the glide feels so soft that few actions seem less troublesome. Two or three hours later the senses return and terrible pain arrives; he is so ill for two or three nights that he thinks he is dying again, this time painfully. The manner of the fall is concealed to favour the rider. When memory returns, the horse at his heels is a flash of lightning that pierced his soul, as if he had come from the other world.

The long story of so light an accident would be vain if it had not taught him that to get acquainted with death a man need only approach it. This is his study, not another man's lesson. Custom makes speaking of oneself vicious, in hatred of boasting; Montaigne says the remedy of cutting off the child's nose is worse than the disease. Forbidding him to speak from his own experience is like enjoining an architect not to speak of building. He does not write his own acts, but himself and his essence. Pride dwells in the thought; the tongue has little share. Whoever looks only downward should turn the eye toward Scipio and Epaminondas and put his weak parts in the other scale. Socrates alone digested the precept to know himself and arrived at setting himself at nought. Whoever shall so know himself may boldly speak it out.

Amplified Discussion
Why We Avoid the Practice Runs That Would Actually Help Us

Montaigne noticed something crucial: ancient philosophers deliberately sought hardship to train themselves, but most people avoid even small discomforts. This pattern persists today. We'll binge-watch leadership videos but avoid having one difficult conversation. We'll read parenting books but never practice setting boundaries with other adults. We'll study interview techniques but never actually practice interviewing. Why? Because practice runs feel real—they trigger the same anxiety as the actual event, so we convince ourselves we're 'not ready yet.' Meanwhile, consuming information feels productive without the emotional cost. But here's what Montaigne discovered through his near-death experience: the anticipation is almost always worse than the reality. When he was healthy, he pitied sick people more than he pitied himself when actually ill. His imagination had made death terrifying, but the actual experience felt peaceful. This reveals a fundamental truth about human psychology—we're terrible at predicting how we'll feel in future situations. We overestimate both our future suffering and our current inability to handle challenges. The solution isn't more preparation through study, but deliberate exposure to manageable versions of what we fear. Every expert started as a beginner who chose practice over preparation.

Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.

AI Discussion
Why it matters

Run the Smaller Ordeal

The hard hour you have only pictured in your head often feels twice as large as the hour you actually walk through. During the civil wars a fellow on a strong German horse knocks Montaigne ten paces from a stunned mount; given over for dead, he glides into a sweetness like sleep, then two or three hours later the bruises arrive in terrible pain. This week, pick one ordeal you have only imagined and run a smaller version that actually loads the nerves, then write whether the picture or the pinch was larger.

Lessons

PracticeThis week, pick one ordeal you have only imagined and run a smaller version that actually loads the nerves, then write whether the picture or the pinch was larger.

Psych reading

The Picture Before the Pinch

A person treats a pictured ordeal as if it were already lived, then meets the real hour and finds the picture was larger than the pinch, or the pinch arrived in a different place.

In the mind

A pictured ordeal often feels already lived, so a person trusts the picture and skips the rehearsal. Montaigne moves from philosophers sallying out to meet fortune, through death's single unrehearsed trial, to the German horse that left him given over for dead, sweet in the swoon and wrecked when sense returned. The mechanism is mistaking a read or imagined hour for a loaded one. A course, a briefing, or a late-night worry can supply the language of courage without ever stressing the nerves. Navigation means designing one smaller repetition that approaches the real stakes, then comparing the picture with the pinch before you rely on the virtue in public. When you can name this pattern, predict where it leads, and adjust before you commit, you have a map for the next time the same pressure appears.

Find the right chapter

Each mood maps to a life skill. Each skill connects to the patterns in classic literature.

😔How do you feel😊

Personalize your match

Optional—life stage, what you need today, and what you're navigating help us pick chapters that fit—not generic lists. You may also freeform using the feeling search below.

Sign in to save your profile

Choices stay on this device until you sign in.

Browse the Full Library
4,582Chapters
118+Books
86Authors