LIVE
OCD← Home
The Essays of Montaigne cover
1580
The Essays of Montaigne
Michel de Montaigne · The Power and Peril of Names
Chapter 46
Ch. 45
Reading
Ch. 46
Ch. 47
Loading audio...
0:000:00

Montaigne will make a hodge-podge of names the way mixed herbs disappear under one name of a sallet. Every nation has names taken, he knows not why, in no good sense: with us, John, William, Benedict. Princes seem to carry fatal names as well: Ptolemies, Henries, Charleses, Baldwins, and the Williams of Aquitaine. At a feast of Henry, Duke of Normandy, the nobility divided for sport by names, and the first troop seated a hundred and ten knights named William, without reckoning ordinary gentlemen and servants. Geta served whole courses by the first letter of the meats. A well-sounding name, easy to say and easy to remember, is convenient besides: kings know us by it, and we call first the servants whose names sit ready on the tongue. Montaigne has seen Henry II unable to hit of a Gascon gentleman's name, and fain to call a maid of honour by the general name of her race. Socrates thinks it worthy a father's care to give fine names to his children.

A name can halt a life. At Poitiers a debauched young fellow asked a wench her name, heard Mary, and felt himself so pierced by that sacred name of the Blessed Virgin that he sent her away and became a reformed man; Notre Dame la Grande rose on the place. That reproof went in by the ear, right into the soul. Pythagoras, seeing wild young fellows complot to violate an honest house, had the singing wench change her wanton airs, and a grave spondaic music laid their ardour asleep. The modern reformation, Montaigne notes, has quarrelled even with Charles, Louis, and Francis, to fill the world with Methuselahs, Ezekiels, and Malachis. A neighbour hears other kind of men in Don Grumedan than in Pierre, Guillot, and Michel. Jacques Amyot pleases him by leaving Latin names entire, because turning Vaudemont into Vallemontanus loses the persons and the story. Worse is the French custom of calling every one by his manor or seigneury. A younger brother's title passes, ten years after his death, into a stranger's hand, and families are confounded; the royal house itself makes a new surname at every partition until the original is lost. Anyone fortune raises gets genealogical titles unknown to his father and is inoculated into some illustrious stem. How many gentlemen in France are, by their own account, of royal extraction? More, Montaigne thinks, than will confess they are not.

Gentlemen assembled about a dispute of seigneury alleged extraction, resemblance of name or arms, an old worm-eaten patent; the least of them was great-grandchild to some foreign king. When they sat down to dinner, a friend of Montaigne's retired with profound conges and said it would ill become him to sit among so many princes. Let us, in God's name, he told them, satisfy ourselves with what our fathers were contented with, with what we are. Arms have no more security than surnames: a son-in-law or a paltry purchaser can carry Montaigne's trefoils and lion's paw into another house. Glory, for which the world is turned upside down, is in the end Peter or William: a sound, or three or four dashes with a pen, so easy to vary that he would fain know whether so many victories belong to Guesquin, Glesquin, or Gueaquin. Denisot built the Count d'Alsinois by anagram and endowed it with his poetry; Suetonius cashiered Lenis for Tranquillus; Captain Bayard's honour is Peter Terrail's deeds under another name. History already knows three Socrateses and eight Aristotles. Who hinders Montaigne's groom from calling himself Pompey the Great? What then fixes those flourishes of the pen upon the deceased groom, or upon the Pompey who had his head cut off in Egypt? Survivors tickle themselves with verses written for Epaminondas and Africanus, and flatter themselves they shall one day wear the same character. Juvenal's commanders have aroused themselves for these: so much greater is the thirst for fame than for virtue.

Amplified Discussion
Why We Fall for Fancy Labels

Montaigne noticed something that still traps us today: we're hardwired to respect symbols over substance. In his time, people fabricated noble genealogies and stole impressive titles. Today, we do the same with LinkedIn profiles, job titles, and social media personas. But why does this work so consistently? Because our brains evolved in small groups where reputation mattered for survival. If someone was called 'the great hunter' or 'the wise elder,' it usually meant something real. Now we live in a world where anyone can claim any title, but our ancient programming still kicks in. We automatically defer to the person called 'Senior Vice President' even when they're less competent than the 'Assistant Manager.' We trust the doctor with the fanciest diploma over the nurse who actually knows what's happening. This isn't stupidity—it's outdated mental software running in a modern context. The solution isn't to ignore all credentials, but to develop better pattern recognition. Ask yourself: Does this person's authority come from their title or their track record? Are they using impressive language to hide weak ideas? When someone name-drops or credential-drops, what are they trying to avoid discussing? The people worth following often have less flashy titles but more substantive results.

Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.

AI Discussion
Why it matters

Strip the Label First

A label can get someone a seat before anyone has watched them work. At a dinner where every guest claimed royal blood, Montaigne's friend withdrew with profound conges and said it would ill become him to sit among so many princes. You can strip the title, the surname, or the display name from one person you are about to defer to this week, write what remains, and judge that remainder first.

Lessons

PracticeYou can strip the title, the surname, or the display name from one person you are about to defer to this week, write what remains, and judge that remainder first.

Psych reading

Mistaking the Label for the Person

A person lets a name, a title, or a flourish of the pen stand in for worth, then inflates or borrows a better label when the old one no longer opens the door.

In the mind

A room will often rank people by what they are called before anyone has watched them work. The heading is easy; the pile underneath is mixed. Sound does real labour. A sacred word can stop a man mid-act and found a church on the spot. A grave tune can cool a riot the mind had already agreed to. Reformers then quarrel with baptism itself, as if a harsher syllable could manufacture a harsher soul. Property titles scramble the trail still further. Land names migrate to strangers; new men stitch themselves onto famous stems; a table of equals becomes a table of invented royalty until one guest stands up and will not play. What remains, after the farce, is a sound or a few marks on paper, shared by grooms and by captains, altered by anagram, inherited by nobody in the grave. Survivors keep hunting that echo. The useful check is to peel the heading off one person you are about to credit, write the remainder, and decide whether you would still stand up.

Find the right chapter

Each mood maps to a life skill. Each skill connects to the patterns in classic literature.

😔How do you feel😊

Personalize your match

Optional—life stage, what you need today, and what you're navigating help us pick chapters that fit—not generic lists. You may also freeform using the feeling search below.

Sign in to save your profile

Choices stay on this device until you sign in.

Browse the Full Library
4,582Chapters
118+Books
86Authors