Reason, Montaigne says, directs that we should always go the same way, but not always at the same pace. A wise man may let passion hasten or slacken his speed without leaving the right path, and without turning into a motionless Colossus. Could virtue itself put on flesh and blood, the pulse would still beat faster going on to assault than going to dinner: she must heat and be moved. What startles him is another kind of stillness. Some great men, in the highest enterprises, keep so settled a calm that they do not break their sleep. Alexander, on the morning of his furious battle with Darius, slept so profoundly that Parmenio had to enter his chamber, come to his bedside, and call him several times by his name before the time to fight could get him up.
The Emperor Otho, having resolved to kill himself that night, settled his house, divided his money, sharpened the sword, and, waiting only to know his friends were safe, snored so that the gentlemen of his chamber heard him. Cato parallels that death. Ready to despatch himself, he stayed his hand until a messenger could say whether the senators were out from the Port of Utica, and they heard him snore in the next room; woken by a storm that kept the ships in harbour, he sent another man, composed himself in the bed again, and slept till the last return. The same Cato, facing Metellus's bid to call Pompey into the city, was to meet a tribune backed by the people, by Caesar, and by a rabble of slaves and gladiators. Friends passed the night without sleep, eating, or drinking. His wife and sisters wept in the house. He comforted them, supped as usual, and slept till a fellow-tribune roused him for the encounter. The rest of his life, Montaigne says, warrants reading that indifference as a soul too high to let the accident take more hold than an ordinary incident.
Augustus, just as the fight with Sextus Pompeius was to begin in Sicily, slept so fast that friends had to wake him to give the signal of battle. Mark Antony later called that a want of courage: he had not beheld his own squadrons with open eyes, and had not dared present himself until Agrippa brought news of the victory. Young Marius did much worse. After marshalling his army against Sylla and giving the word, he laid him down under a tree and slept so fast that the rout and flight of his men could hardly waken him; he had seen nothing of the fight. Labour and want of sleep had spent him; nature could hold out no longer. Physicians may now say whether our lives depend upon sleep. Perseus of Macedon, prisoner at Rome, was killed by being kept from it. Pliny names men who lived long without it. Herodotus speaks of nations that sleep and wake by half-years, and the life of Epimenides says he slept seven-and-fifty years together. The same closed eyes can look like a soul above accident, like a body that has given out, or like a riddle no physician has closed.
Montaigne's observation about sleep before major events reveals something crucial about our current moment. We live in an age of unprecedented anxiety, where sleeping pills are a multi-billion dollar industry and 'Sunday scaries' are a recognised phenomenon. But what if our sleeplessness isn't a medical condition—what if it's information? When Alexander slept before battle, it wasn't because he was disconnected from reality. He'd prepared extensively, surrounded himself with capable generals, and aligned his actions with his vision of leadership. His calm came from internal coherence, not external circumstances. Today, we're often anxious because we're living divided lives—saying yes when we mean no, pursuing goals that don't reflect our values, or taking shortcuts that compromise our integrity. The gig economy forces many people into work that feels misaligned with their principles. Social media creates pressure to present false versions of ourselves. We're encouraged to optimize everything except the fundamental question: are we being authentic to who we really are? Montaigne suggests that true confidence isn't about feeling fearless—it's about the deep peace that comes from knowing you've done your homework and stayed true to your values. In a culture that sells us external solutions to internal conflicts, this ancient insight offers a different path: instead of managing anxiety, we might ask what it's trying to tell us.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion