LIVE
OCD← Home
The Essays of Montaigne cover
1580
The Essays of Montaigne
Michel de Montaigne · Why Luxury Bans Backfire
Chapter 43
Ch. 42
Reading
Ch. 43
Ch. 44
Loading audio...
0:000:00

Montaigne says the laws that try to curb idle expense in meat and clothes work against their own end. The true way would be to beget in men a contempt of silks and gold as vain, frivolous, and useless. Instead those laws augment the honours of such things and enhance their value. To enact that none but princes shall eat turbot, or wear velvet or gold lace, and to interdict those things to the people, is only to bring them into greater esteem and set everyone more agog to eat and wear them. Kings have other ensigns of grandeur; these excesses are more excusable in anyone else than in a prince. Distinction of quality is still requisite in a state, but other nations mark it without this corruption.

Custom in indifferent things establishes itself with strange speed and becomes authority. France had scarce worn cloth a year, in compliance with the court mourning for Henry II, before silks grew into such contempt that a man so clad was presently concluded a citizen. Silks were divided betwixt the physicians and surgeons, and even when almost everyone went in the same habit, some one mark still distinguished the several conditions of men. Greasy chamois and linen doublets become the fashion in the armies, while richness of habit falls into contempt. Let kings but lead the dance and begin to leave off this expense, and in a month the business will be done throughout the kingdom, without edict or ordinance. It should rather be proclaimed that no one should wear scarlet or goldsmiths' work but courtesans and tumblers. Zeleucus reclaimed the Locrians by that same invention: jewels, embroidered robes, and gold rings were left to drunk women, public prostitutes, and bravos, so that infamous exceptions diverted citizens from superfluities by honour and ambition rather than by force.

Our kings can do what they please in such external reformations; their own inclination stands for a law. What princes themselves do, they seem to prescribe, and whatever is done at court passes for a rule through the rest of France. Let the courtiers fall out with the abominable breeches, the great bellied doublets unfit for arms, the long effeminate locks, and the foolish kissing of equals. Let them not permit a gentleman to appear without his sword, unbuttoned as though from the house of office, or to stand a long time bare to so many petty kings. These errors look superficial, yet they are of ill augury: the whole fabric is crazy and tottering when the roughcast of the walls begins to cleave. Plato esteems nothing more pestiferous than giving young men liberty to hunt novelty in habits, dances, and songs until old institutions are nauseated. The laws that keep their true credit are those whose beginning no one knows, or that there ever was any other.

Amplified Discussion
Why Banning Things Makes Them More Popular

Montaigne discovered something that modern psychology confirms: humans are wired to want what they can't have. When authorities say 'only certain people can have this,' they accidentally turn ordinary items into symbols of power and freedom. This isn't just about luxury goods—it's about how our brains process scarcity and rebellion. Think about how prohibition made alcohol more glamorous in the 1920s, or how banned books become bestsellers. The pattern repeats in workplaces where strict rules about personal expression often create underground cultures of resistance. Parents see this daily: forbid your teenager from seeing someone, and suddenly that person becomes irresistible. The mistake authorities make is thinking they can control desire through law. But desire doesn't follow legal logic—it follows emotional logic. When you tell someone they can't have something because they're not 'worthy' enough, you've just made that thing a symbol of worthiness. Smart leaders understand this and work with human nature instead of against it. They create positive examples rather than negative rules. They make good choices look appealing rather than making bad choices illegal. The question becomes: when you need to influence behaviour, are you accidentally making the unwanted behaviour more attractive by forbidding it?

Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.

AI Discussion
Why it matters

Write What the Ban Advertises

When a rule reserves the casual dress, the late start, or the special kit for a few people, the rest of the room learns what winning looks like. Montaigne says to enact that none but princes may eat turbot or wear velvet is only to set everyone more agog to eat and wear them, while Zeleucus reserved jewels and embroidered robes for prostitutes and so made the luxury look cheap. This week, before you forbid a status marker, write what the ban advertises, then either drop the marker yourself or attach it to a cost that kills the glamour.

Lessons

PracticeThis week, before you forbid a status marker, write what the ban advertises, then either drop the marker yourself or attach it to a cost that kills the glamour.

Psych reading

The Privilege Advertisement

A person tries to suppress a status appetite by forbidding the badge to most people, and thereby advertises the badge as the mark of rank.

In the mind

People try to kill a vain appetite by reserving the object for elites, and thereby teach everyone else that the object is the badge of rank. Montaigne watches sumptuary laws set France agog for turbot and velvet, then watches mourning cloth for Henry II make silk look citizenly, then watches Zeleucus dump jewels onto prostitutes so honour would flee the excess. The same rebound appears when a firm lets only partners skip the uniform, or a school bans a shoe until the shoe becomes the identity. Navigation means changing what looks admirable: drop the badge yourself, or attach it to a cost that kills the glamour, before you write the ban that advertises it. When you can name this pattern, predict where it leads, and adjust before you commit, you have a map for the next time the same pressure appears.

Find the right chapter

Each mood maps to a life skill. Each skill connects to the patterns in classic literature.

😔How do you feel😊

Personalize your match

Optional—life stage, what you need today, and what you're navigating help us pick chapters that fit—not generic lists. You may also freeform using the feeling search below.

Sign in to save your profile

Choices stay on this device until you sign in.

Browse the Full Library
4,582Chapters
118+Books
86Authors