On the June evening when Farebrother learns he is to have the Lowick living, joy fills the old parlor: his mother says the greatest comfort is that he has deserved it; he answers that half the deserving must come after. He jokes with Miss Noble about sugar-candy and with Winifred about marriage, says he will be too busy for whist with two parishes, and has told Dorothea he will not surrender St. Botolph's but will use power well while she felt she ought not let patronage pass to another.
Conscience sharpens with ease; he admits past laches to Lydgate and hopes to make a good clergyman from the well-beneficed point of view. Duty arrives disguised as Fred Vincy, newly degreed, ashamed to trouble him again. Fred sees no path but the Church though he dislikes divinity and preaching; he loves Mary Garth, who forbade him to speak and rejects his becoming a clergyman. He asks Farebrother to learn her feeling, saying if she would never have him he might as well go wrong one way as another.
Farebrother rides to Lowick parsonage, finds Mary scolding her terrier Fly in the rose garden, and speaks gently of Fred's request. He clears her guilt about Featherstone's will: the first will would not have stood. Mary says she could never love a man who is ridiculous and Fred as a clergyman would be professional affectation; she will not promise marriage until he earns regard, though her feeling for Fred is too deep to give him up for anyone else. A flash suggests Farebrother's tone may mean more than Fred's cause; she answers plainly. He rides back having done a duty harder than renouncing whist.
Chapter LII balances joy and renunciation. The Farebrother parlor is tender comedy; Fred's entrance is Duty with a broken leg. Mary's speech against imbecile gentility in the Church is Eliot's plain ethics. She will not promise marriage without worth, yet will not transfer her heart. Farebrother's suppressed feeling in the maple shade is the chapter's hidden river. Dorothy who only tracks Fred and Mary as a love triangle misses Dorothea's earlier choice of this man over Tyke. Middlemarch links patronage, vocation, and sacrifice: the living goes to one who will use it well and immediately prove it by losing a private hope.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion