The provincial town is under a young, progressive, despotic governor who has already quarrelled with his council and his staff. A commissary has been sent to investigate: Matvei Ilyitch Koliazin, a little over forty, hungry for stars on his breast, progressive like the man he has come to examine, and vain enough to wear a fixed air of simplicity. He has a pleasant laugh and is often set down as a fool. Officials of more experience ride over him. He esteems Guizot, studies contemporary literature with a careless pomp, and will sometimes join a street procession of students. In matters of state he has no common sense. He welcomes Arkady with the jocosity of an enlightened bigwig, and his face falls when he hears that the other relatives stayed in the country. Your father always was a queer fish, he says, parting the tails of a velvet coat. Then he turns on a young clerk whose lips look gummed shut, and settles him. The method is a favourite. A bigwig suddenly cannot understand the simplest sentence. What day is it? Friday, your Excellency. What do you mean by Friday? Friday is a day in the week. You need not have taken so much time to tell me that. Matvei calls himself a Liberal.
He advises Arkady to leave a card on the Governor. Not, he says, because he holds with old ideas of bowing to authority, but because the Governor is a good fellow, and Byronism has had its day. Arkady begins to say that he belongs neither to the Byronists nor to anyone else, and is cut off. Matvei will take him under his wing. A servant announces the President of the Provincial Treasury, a mild veteran who likes to say that every little bee is taking its toll of every little flower. Arkady uses the entrance to leave.
At the hotel he has trouble persuading Bazarov to call on the Governor. At last Bazarov says he has laid a hand on the tow-rope, so he will not complain of its weight. They have come to inspect the local lions. Let them inspect them. The Governor gives a civil welcome, asks neither of them to sit, invites them to the ball, and two minutes later invites them again as if he had not. Throughout he takes them for brothers and calls them the Messieurs Kaiserov. On the way back a small man in Slavophil costume leaps from a drozhki and throws himself on Bazarov. Sitnikov. He had left a card at the hotel, corners turned down, his name in French on one side and in Slavonic letters on the other. He tells Arkady that through Bazarov he came by his spiritual regeneration. There is a lady who will understand Bazarov, Madame Evdoksia Kukshin, an emancipée. She lives two steps away and will give them luncheon, and champagne. She is not exactly good-looking. Then why go, Bazarov asks. Sitnikov giggles and offers a bottle, then a bottle apiece, and bails the promise with his head. A purse would have been better, Bazarov says. But lead on.
Turgenev captured something timeless about how power disguises itself. In 1862 Russia, Koliazin called himself a liberal while behaving like any petty tyrant. Today, we see the same pattern everywhere: managers who preach 'collaborative leadership' while micromanaging every decision, politicians who champion 'transparency' while hiding their real agenda, family members who talk about 'healthy communication' but explode when anyone disagrees. The language evolves - from 'liberal' to 'progressive' to 'collaborative' - but the underlying hunger for control remains unchanged. What makes this particularly insidious is that it creates cognitive dissonance. We hear the right words and want to believe them, even when our gut tells us something's off. The person using progressive language often believes their own rhetoric, convinced they're different from old-school authoritarians while using identical tactics. This self-deception makes them even more dangerous because they're not consciously manipulating - they genuinely think they're the good guys. Recognition becomes our defence. When someone constantly announces how progressive or collaborative they are, that's often a red flag. True progressives don't need to constantly advertise it. They demonstrate it through consistent actions, especially in how they treat people with less power. The question becomes: In your own life, where have you encountered this gap between progressive words and controlling actions?
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion