It is a Sunday afternoon in February, dinner is over, and Bathsheba has asked Liddy to sit with her for want of a better companion. The old farmhouse is dreary before the candles are lit, and the new piano, which is an old one with a history of its own, slopes on the warped floor. Liddy ripples on like a shallow brook. She points to the leather Bible on the table and asks if her mistress ever found out whom she will marry by the Bible and key. Bathsheba calls it nonsense, then springs from her seat and says, “Very well, let’s try it.” Liddy frets that it is Sunday. “What’s right week days is right Sundays,” says Bathsheba. She puts the key on a verse in the Book of Ruth, blushes, and will not say whom she tried.
Liddy’s mind has already moved to Boldwood. His pew is exactly opposite Bathsheba’s, and he did not turn his head to her once in the whole service, though everyone else did. Bathsheba says she did not ask him to, in a nettled voice. She remembers the valentine she bought for little Teddy Coggan, and when Liddy asks if it is for Boldwood, the name seems to her more fitting than the right one. Liddy’s joke about sending it to “the stupid old Boldwood” first annoys her, for he has become a troublesome image, a Daniel who kneels eastward while everyone else follows suit and glances her way. They will not toss money on a Sunday, so they toss a hymn-book. It lands shut, which means Boldwood, and Bathsheba writes his name with a yawn.
She tries a unicorn’s head and two doves for a seal, and then one with a motto she cannot read. In the hot wax Liddy reads: “MARRY ME.” Bathsheba cries “Capital!” and says it would upset the solemnity of a parson and clerk. Hardy gives his verdict on the afternoon: the deed was done so idly that of love as a spectacle she knew something, but of love as a feeling she knew nothing. That night the letter goes to the Casterbridge post-office, to come back to Weatherbury in the morning.
Hardy understood something profound about human psychology: indifference wounds us deeper than active dislike. When someone criticizes us, at least they're engaging—they see us as worth their energy. But when someone treats us as if we don't exist? That hits our fundamental need to matter. Bathsheba can handle the older farmers who might question her methods or experience. What she can't handle is Boldwood's complete lack of reaction to her presence. In Hardy's time, this played out in drawing rooms and social gatherings. Today, it shows up everywhere: the coworker who gets promoted while you're overlooked, the family member who responds to everyone's texts except yours, the neighbor who waves at everyone on the street but walks past you like you're invisible. The pattern is ancient and universal. We tell ourselves we don't care what others think, but our actions reveal the truth. We post on social media hoping for responses. We volunteer for projects to get noticed. We sometimes create drama just to force acknowledgment. The danger isn't in wanting to be seen—that's human. The danger is in the lengths we'll go to force recognition from people whose attention shouldn't define our worth. Hardy shows us that the people whose indifference bothers us most often reveal our deepest insecurities about ourselves.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion