John sets aside many imperfections and keeps the ones that cause the rest. Under luxury, apart from what belongs to spiritual matters, beginners meet a spiritual impurity he says is beyond enumeration. In the exercises themselves, when they are powerless to prevent it, impure acts and motions assert themselves in the sensual part, sometimes at prayer, at the Sacrament of Penance, or at the Eucharist.
These things do not come from the subject of the devotion. They come from the stirrings of concupiscence. The devil, seeing them unprepared, assails them with strong temptations of this kind, so he may disturb and disquiet their spirits and make them loathe the spiritual life. When the motions happen during the exercises, they are made to believe they must have committed grave sin.
John calls that belief a misunderstanding. What they met was a natural rebellion of sensuality, often beyond their control. The flicker is not the verdict. The verdict they pass on themselves is what drives them to loathe the practice. Loathing the spiritual life is the result the temptation is built to produce. Control was never the test. The test was whether a motion beyond control gets called a grave sin. Shame does the rest.
Saint Juan identified something we still struggle with today: the disconnect between our physical responses and our conscious goals. In his time, people felt ashamed when their bodies reacted during prayer. Today, we feel the same shame when our minds wander during important conversations, when we get aroused at inappropriate times, or when we feel hungry during solemn moments. The pattern hasn't changed—only the context. This disconnect isn't a personal failing; it's how humans are wired. Our nervous system, hormones, and unconscious mind operate independently of our conscious intentions. The real trap isn't the physical response—it's the shame spiral that follows. When we interpret every bodily reaction as evidence of our character, we set ourselves up for failure. The person whose stomach growls during a funeral doesn't lack respect for the deceased. The parent whose mind wanders during their child's recital isn't a bad parent. The student who feels sleepy during an important lecture isn't uncommitted to learning. These are just bodies being bodies. The wisdom lies in recognizing this pattern and refusing to let temporary physical states define our worth or derail our progress. When we can separate what we can control from what we can't, we stop wasting energy on shame and redirect it towards actual growth.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion