Many beginners are discontented with the spirituality God gives them. They grow disconsolate and querulous because they do not find the consolation they desire. They can never have enough of counsels, precepts, and books on the matter, and they spend their time on those rather than on mortification and the inward poverty of spirit that should be theirs.
They also burden themselves with curious images and rosaries. They put one down and take another up, change about and change back, and prefer one cross because it is more curious. Others go about adorned with agnus deis, relics, and tokens, like children with trinkets. The objects keep changing. The want for a sweeter spirituality does not.
John says he condemns the attachment of the heart and the possessiveness that regards these things, because that is contrary to poverty of spirit. The books and the tokens can stay in the room. What he will not leave standing is the heart that treats them as proof it is advancing. Poverty of spirit is the work they keep postponing while the rosaries change hands. The querulous want does not become mortification by adding another book. The heart stays possessive. Another token will not cure it.
Juan of the Cross identified something that feels remarkably contemporary: the way people can turn even spiritual growth into another form of materialism. In his time, it was collecting religious objects and switching between spiritual directors. Today, it's the explosion of the wellness industry, where spiritual practices become products to consume rather than disciplines to embody. The pattern reveals something deeper about human nature: when we're uncomfortable with ourselves, we often try to solve it by acquiring something external. This creates what psychologists now call 'retail therapy' or 'information hoarding'—the illusion that having more will make us feel better. But Juan understood that real transformation requires what he called 'poverty of spirit'—a willingness to sit with discomfort without immediately reaching for a solution to buy, consume, or collect. The irony is that our consumer culture has turned even anti-materialism into a material pursuit. You can buy minimalism courses, purchase meditation apps, and accumulate mindfulness books. The question becomes: when does seeking help become avoiding the very thing that would actually help us? How do we distinguish between genuine growth and spiritual consumerism dressed up as self-improvement?
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion