LIVE
OCD← Home
Crime and Punishment cover
1866
Crime and Punishment
Fyodor Dostoevsky · Me or Luzhin
Chapter 15
Ch. 14
Reading
Ch. 15
Ch. 16
Loading audio...
0:000:00

Raskolnikov wakes from his faint to find Pulcheria and Dunya at his bedside, faces agonized and hands trembling. He cuts off Razumihin's warm consolations, grips mother and sister, and in a broken voice sends them away with him for the night. When his mother vows to stay, he cries don't torture me. Dunya whispers them out. Alone with his family gone, he rallies enough to deliver a command: he does not want that marriage; at the first opportunity tomorrow Dunya must refuse Luzhin so they never hear his name again. This marriage is an infamy. He will act like a scoundrel, but they must not. It's me or Luzhin. Go now. He turns to the wall and will not hear another word.

Razumihin bustles as nurse and host, then escorts the ladies down the dark stairs, scolding Nastasya and the landlady. He warns that Rodya slipped out today while delirious, that the Bakaleyev lodgings Luzhin chose are foul, and that the family must not tell Rodya about a letter or anything that could shock him. At the street door he learns they arrived that evening on a late train. His devotion is clumsy but fierce: he will sit up all night, chase visitors from his own party, and keep the invalid in sight.

On the pavement Razumihin, drunk from his uncle's champagne, becomes eloquent and unguarded. He kisses the ladies' hands, praises Dunya's beauty, and declares that to go wrong in one's own way is better than to go right in someone else's. Then he blurts what he has seen: your fiancé is a scoundrel. Pulcheria is scandalized; Dunya flushes. He insists Luzhin is unworthy, describes the wretched rooms, and offers himself as protector while stumbling through the night air.

Zossimov follows to consult. In the ladies' new lodging he diagnoses something approaching a monomania, urges quiet and no upsetting news, and promises a calm visit at ten tomorrow. Razumihin's jealousy flickers when the doctor praises Dunya's looks. The two young men half quarrel over who may help. Razumihin swears he will bring Raskolnikov to the ladies in the morning. Dunya has heard the ultimatum and has not yet answered it.

Amplified Discussion
Why He Says Me or Luzhin

Part III Chapter I is family politics, not police games. Raskolnikov has fainted before love; he wakes commanding. Refuse Luzhin tomorrow is the first moral act he can perform without confessing murder. He calls the marriage infamy and adds me or Luzhin, turning Dunya's sacrifice into a loyalty test he has no right to frame, yet must. Turning to the wall is both illness and power: he ends discussion. Razumihin fills the vacuum: nurse, bouncer, escort, drunk truth-teller. On the stairs he guards shocks; on the pavement he kisses hands and names the fiancé a scoundrel. Zossimov's monomania almost labels the crime. Jealousy and matchmaking jokes show two young men orbiting Dunya while she has not yet spoken her choice. The chapter prepares tomorrow: ten o'clock, a letter, Marmeladov's money, Luzhin's reply. Raskolnikov has not healed; he has redirected crisis onto the marriage, the one wound he can touch without naming the axe.

Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.

AI Discussion
Why it matters

Blocking a Harmful Match Without Full Disclosure

When you cannot tell the whole story, you can still forbid one concrete harm. Raskolnikov orders Dunya to refuse Luzhin at the first opportunity tomorrow, then turns to the wall; later Razumihin calls the fiancé a scoundrel on the pavement. This week, name one match, loan, or job you can oppose without explaining every reason, and write the sentence you would actually say.

Lessons

In the mind

THE PATTERN: You cannot confess the real crime, so you veto the marriage, exile comfort, and let a loyal friend insult the fiancé for you.

THE MECHANISM: Mother and sister arrive into post-faint shock. Raskolnikov refuses Luzhin tomorrow, demands me or Luzhin, turns to the wall. Razumihin manages stairs, warns of today's escape and bad lodgings, then on the pavement calls Luzhin a scoundrel. Zossimov labels monomania and orders calm. The family is reunited but the engagement is fractured.

THE MODERN PARALLEL: The sibling who returns from crisis and forbids a parent's exploitative partner without saying why. The friend who walks relatives home and says what the patient cannot.

THE NAVIGATION: When you lack full honesty, still block concrete harms you can name. Let allies speak if you cannot. Accept medical framing that protects rest without replacing truth. Watch when devotion becomes control from friends as well as patients.

Find the right chapter

Each mood maps to a life skill. Each skill connects to the patterns in classic literature.

😔How do you feel😊

Personalize your match

Optional—life stage, what you need today, and what you're navigating help us pick chapters that fit—not generic lists. You may also freeform using the feeling search below.

Sign in to save your profile

Choices stay on this device until you sign in.

Browse the Full Library
4,582Chapters
118+Books
86Authors