The question stays with Adams even at work. He tells his wife he is the biggest fool alive for worrying about what Lamb thinks. She is gentle with him now, and for the first time in years he sits and talks with her in the evenings. She says Lamb has probably forgotten, and points out that Walter still has his job, so there can be no hard feeling. Adams is not comforted. Lamb never really forgets, he says, and keeping Walter on might be one more way of making him feel mean. Then he admits what he left out of his letter: the process is just about the same as the one Lamb paid him and Campbell to work out. Nobody could tell the difference. Lamb cannot take him to law, he says. The worst he could do is tell people his side.
Adams had always supposed that taking the formula would bring overwhelming shame. Instead he feels a constant curiosity about the old man's thoughts, and a dread of meeting him. He avoids the wholesale district. Once he sees Lamb pass in his car without noticing him, and shivers for an hour afterwards. Meanwhile the work eats money: high wages, vats, boilers, raw material. Six weeks after the lease, glue-making begins, and terrible smells writhe through that quarter of town like snakes. At home, after a hot bath and fresh clothes, he keeps asking his wife and Alice whether they can smell it on him. They cannot. To him the whole town smells of his glue-works.
Still, the sheds are busy. His foreman says he has woken up the neighbourhood: the huge dead butterine factory across the street is being rebuilt by some big corporation. Adams is pleased, sure that one man's enterprise has drawn another. He has hired young women to do the bottling and expects his banker to carry him. Sitting outside with his wife at dusk, he admits the business looks good. She asks whether he will grant that she was right. He calls it a puzzle. Above them, Alice sings 'Mi chiamo Mimi' with startling sweetness. She is terribly in love, her mother says. Adams wonders what all their muck and moil was for, if Alice was going to go her own way regardless. Then Mrs. Adams remembers something. Russell has never once been inside their house.
Virgil Adams has everything he thought he wanted, money, respect, opportunities for his family, yet he's more miserable than when he was struggling. This paradox reveals something crucial about human psychology that hasn't changed in over a century. We're wired to feel good about achievements that align with our values and terrible about ones that don't, regardless of external rewards. In 1921, this meant stolen business formulas. Today, it might mean inflated resumes, taking credit for others' work, or cutting corners that compromise safety or quality. The pattern remains: when we violate our core principles to achieve our goals, the victory becomes a prison. Modern culture often dismisses this as 'imposter syndrome' or tells us to 'fake it till you make it,' but Tarkington shows us something deeper. The anxiety isn't irrational, it's our conscience demanding integrity. The solution isn't better self-talk or confidence building. It's honest self-assessment about our methods. Sometimes the bravest thing we can do is admit we took a shortcut, accept the consequences, and rebuild on solid ground. The temporary setback of honesty often leads to more sustainable success than the constant anxiety of deception. When have you achieved something that should have felt good but didn't?
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion