After the mercantile system, Smith turns to French writers who said the produce of land is the sole source of a nation's wealth. No country, so far as he knows, ever adopted that system. It lived in the speculations of a few men of great learning and ingenuity in France. It would not be worth a long refutation, he says, except that the errors still show how a single-industry obsession distorts policy. Colbert, serving Louis XIV, had already bent the rod toward towns. Corn export bans and provincial grain restraints cheapened bread for manufacturers and beggared cultivators. The Economists, seeing that injury, bent the other way and treated only the soil as truly productive. If the rod is bent too far one way, the proverb says, straighten it by bending the other. They bent toward land alone. Smith will explain the physiocratic system because it is ingenious, not because it ever governed a people.
Their table sorted society into proprietors, cultivators, and a barren class of merchants, manufacturers, and officials. Farm spending, they said, replaces its own value and adds rent. The expense laid out on artificers and manufacturers does no more than continue the existence of its own value, and is therefore a barren expense. Mercantile stock they classed with manufacturing stock: it moves value around and yields the trader only the repayment of his own maintenance. Smith grants the grain of truth. Land can yield a neat produce after wages and profit, and that surplus is rent. The farmer's stock yields a profit and a rent to someone else; the master manufacturer's stock yields a profit only. Ground expenses on improvement, the Economists insisted, must not be rack-rented away, and Smith borrows that caution. He refuses the insult that follows. A shoemaker who turns leather into shoes leaves a vendible commodity. A weaver's cloth remains after wages and profit are replaced. A menial servant's work perishes in the instant of performance. We should not call a marriage barren only because it replaces the parents without increasing the species. Calling the weaver barren because he pays no rent confuses an accounting line with real production. The lace calculation that seems to multiply labour seven thousand times dazzles the book without adding a harvest.
The practical sting is trade between town and country. Farmers need buyers for grain, wool, and meat; towns need food and materials. A landed nation that first improves its own soil will, in time, raise a surplus capital that turns of itself to home artificers, who have materials and subsistence at hand and can undersell distant mercantile states. Restrain manufactures and foreign trade in order to glorify agriculture, and you raise the price of what the farmer buys while shrinking the home market for what he sells. Rent depends on buyers as well as on soil. A depressed town is a poor customer. Smith notes that French agriculture did shed some oppressions after the Economists protested, and he praises that. Their barren label on urban trades remained a dangerous guide for legislators who love a neat table. Crush those artificers by statute and the surplus of the field has nowhere useful to go. The superior produce of farmers does not, Smith insists, render merchants and makers barren. It is improper to class them with menial servants, whose work never fixes itself in a saleable commodity that can replace their wages and maintenance.
The best connected account of the doctrine, he says, is Mercier de la Rivière's little book on the natural and essential order of political societies, and the sect's admiration for Quesnay rivalled any ancient school for its founder. Mirabeau called the economical table one of three great inventions, beside writing and money, a discovery of which posterity would reap the benefit. Smith answers with natural liberty. The establishment of perfect justice, perfect liberty, and perfect equality is the simple secret that most effectually secures prosperity to all three classes. Let capital seek the highest honest return without a minister choosing whether plough or loom deserves favour. Colbert depressed the countryside to feed towns; Quesnay's disciples would have depressed towns to glorify land. Ancient republics had their own version of the same trick: some Greek states banned foreign trade, and at Athens and Rome the great body of town trades sat with the slaves of the rich, so a poor freeman could hardly find a market. Slaves, Smith notes, are very seldom inventive. Both Colbert and Quesnay picked a favourite sector and renamed the rest. Take away systems of preference and of restraint, and the obvious system of natural liberty establishes itself of its own accord. The tables still tempt anyone who wants a country to have one real industry. The open question is whether a statesman can look at a chart that calls a whole class barren and still leave people free to truck with one another.
Smith's critique of the Physiocrats reveals something crucial about human psychology: the more expert we become in one area, the more likely we are to dismiss value we don't understand. The French economists weren't stupid - they were brilliant scholars who studied agriculture intensively. But their expertise became a trap. They saw farmers feeding everyone and concluded this was the only 'real' work. They couldn't see how a shoemaker turning leather into shoes, or a merchant connecting distant markets, also created genuine value. This pattern repeats constantly in modern workplaces. The engineer who dismisses the janitor's equipment observations because 'what does he know about machinery?' The nurse manager who ignores CNAs' patient insights because 'I have the degree.' The regional manager who cuts local staff because 'the numbers say they're not productive' - without understanding how they prevent costly problems. What makes this dangerous isn't malice, but confidence. Expertise gives us deep knowledge in our domain, which breeds certainty about what matters. That certainty can blind us to value created outside our specialty. The antidote isn't to distrust experts, but to recognize that expertise has limits. Every role, every perspective, every type of work potentially creates value - even if it doesn't fit our mental framework.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion