Morris comes again without managing the last parting. He blames Mrs Penniman for dragging him into the mess and not paving his retreat with flowers. Lavinia, seeing Catherine's room look like a trousseau, takes fright and puts the great scene off from day to day. Catherine has no suspicion. She waits for him to name the day as a favour, not a demand. The air has no perfume. She asks if he is sick. He looks pale and restless. He says he does not want to owe her everything. He is too proud. She will take him as he is.
He tries to pick a quarrel and cannot. She has such treasures of concession. Then he asks if a business trip would seem strange. New Orleans, he says, to buy cotton, six thousand dollars. There is yellow fever. He will not expose her. She will go anyway. She is not afraid of fever. When persons are going to be married they ought not to think so much about business. She has never asked him anything before. They have waited too long. He calls it a scene.
He will transact by letter, he says, and begins to smooth his hat. She wants him tomorrow. He offers Saturday. He is a busy man, not a dangler. She leans on the door and tells him, low and certain, that he is going to leave her. Yes, for a little while, till she is reasonable. She has given up everything. He will write. That is better. She bursts into tears and says he will not come back. Dear Catherine, he answers, do not believe that I promise you that you shall see me again. He gets away and closes the door.
Morris's elaborate New Orleans scheme reveals a pattern that transcends centuries: when people want out but can't face being the bad guy, they manufacture increasingly complex situations hoping the other person will do the dirty work. This isn't just about romantic relationships - it's about how power and responsibility intersect with human cowardice. The person with more to lose (Morris needs Catherine's money) often becomes the person most invested in avoiding direct confrontation. They'd rather create an elaborate fiction than risk being seen as the villain. What makes this particularly cruel is how it forces the other person into an impossible position. Catherine can either play along with the charade, knowing it's false, or call it out and become the 'unreasonable' one who 'doesn't understand' his important business needs. This dynamic appears everywhere in working-class life: employers who make jobs unbearable instead of laying people off, landlords who create problems hoping tenants will move, family members who become impossible instead of setting boundaries directly. The pattern reveals something deeper about how society teaches us to avoid difficult conversations. We're so afraid of being the bad guy that we'll torture people with elaborate deceptions rather than have one honest, painful conversation. But Catherine's clear-eyed responses show another way: refuse to enable the fiction, ask direct questions, and force people to either commit to their stated intentions or admit what's really happening.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion