That evening in the back parlour Mrs Penniman tells Catherine she has met Morris. The girl starts with pain, then a flash of anger almost new to her. She says she does not think it was right. No one but she should see him, because her father forbade it. Lavinia wraps herself in the evening paper and waits to be asked. After a long silence Catherine asks what he said. He is ready to marry in spite of everything. He looked handsome and haggard, brilliantly miserable. Lavinia places the meeting at a confectioner's in the Bowery, then asks why Catherine is so dry.
When pressed about fear, Catherine admits she is afraid of her father. Lavinia pushes her not to disappoint that gallant young heart, and says she was told to use her influence. Catherine grows stern. She does not think her aunt knows her. She forbids further secret appointments. It cannot be right to deceive, and she does not believe Morris himself likes meeting in secret.
Lavinia protests that gentlemen enjoy such things and that Catherine is jealous and thankless. She will never again take a step on her behalf. Then she offers a brief good-night and withdraws to her own apartment.
Mrs. Penniman's reaction to Catherine's boundary reveals something uncomfortable: the people closest to us often have the most invested in our compliance. When Catherine finally says 'no more secret meetings,' her aunt doesn't respect this reasonable request. Instead, she escalates, guilt trips, accusations of jealousy, claims of ingratitude. This isn't coincidence. Mrs. Penniman has built her identity around managing Catherine's romantic life. Catherine's newfound assertiveness threatens that role. The aunt has been the go-between, the helper, the one with special access to Morris. If Catherine starts handling her own relationships, what's Mrs. Penniman's purpose? This dynamic plays out everywhere today. Family members who've always given unsolicited advice suddenly feel displaced when you start making your own decisions. Coworkers who've thrived on being indispensable get hostile when you become more independent. Friends who've positioned themselves as your protector resist your growth. The closer the relationship, the more intense the pushback can be. They're not necessarily bad people, they're humans whose sense of purpose has been disrupted. But recognizing this pattern helps you stay steady when the people you love most start punishing you for growing up. Catherine's strength isn't in avoiding conflict, but in maintaining her boundaries despite the emotional cost.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion