At the beginning of winter Princess Mary comes to Moscow. From reports in town she learns how the Rostovs are situated, and how the son has sacrificed himself for his mother. She feels a joyous sense of her love for him. Remembering her almost familial friendship with the Rostovs, she thinks it her duty to call, yet remembering Voronezh she is shy. Making a great effort she goes a few weeks after her arrival. Nicholas is the first to meet her, because the countess's room can only be reached through his. Instead of pleasure, his face assumes a cold, stiff, proud expression she has not seen before. He inquires about her health, leads her to his mother, sits five minutes, and leaves. Afterward he accompanies her to the anteroom with marked solemnity. To remarks about his mother's health he makes no reply. His looks seem to say, leave me in peace. When her carriage has gone he says aloud in Sonya's presence that he cannot bear these ladies and their civilities. Sonya, hardly able to conceal her delight, cries that Mary is kind and Mamma is fond of her. After the visit the old countess sings Mary's praises several times a day, insists that her son must call, and yet becomes ill-humoured whenever she talks of her. Nicholas's silence irritates her.
He does call, to fulfil politeness. Mary, seeing that, resolves to maintain his tone. They speak of the countess's health, mutual friends, war news. When the ten minutes required by propriety have elapsed, he rises. At the last moment Mary is so tired of talking of what does not interest her, and so full of the question why she alone is granted so little happiness, that she sits still with luminous eyes, not noticing he has risen. He glances, feels sorry, is vaguely conscious that he may be the cause of the sadness, and can think of nothing pleasant to say. Good-bye, Princess. She starts, flushes, sighs, begs pardon, remembers a cushion for the countess. Bourienne leaves to fetch it. They sit silent. Nicholas says with a sad smile that it does not seem long since they first met. There are a thousand reasons why, he adds, laying emphasis on the why. Thank you, Princess. Sometimes it is hard.
So that is why, a voice whispers in Mary's soul. It was not only the gay, kind look she loved. She divined a noble, self-sacrificing spirit. He is poor now and she is rich. That is the only reason. Looking at his kind, sorrowful face she understands the coldness. Why, Count, why? She almost cries, moving closer. You wish to deprive me of our former friendship, and that hurts me. I have had so little happiness that every loss is hard. Excuse me, good-bye. She begins to cry and hurries from the room. He tries to stop her. For a few seconds they gaze silently into one another's eyes, and what had seemed impossible and remote suddenly becomes possible, inevitable, and very near.
Nicholas and Princess Mary's dance around class differences reveals something profound about how shame operates in our relationships. Nicholas isn't pulling away because he doesn't care, he's pulling away because he cares too much and feels unworthy. This creates a cruel irony: the very people we most want to connect with become the ones we most need to protect ourselves from, because they represent everything we think we can't have or don't deserve. In 1869 Russia, rigid class structures made these barriers seem insurmountable. Today, we've replaced formal class lines with subtler but equally powerful markers: education levels, neighborhood zip codes, job titles, family backgrounds. The CNA who won't date the teacher because 'he's too good for me.' The factory worker who becomes hostile toward the college-educated supervisor who's genuinely trying to help. The single parent who stops accepting invitations from friends who seem to 'have it all together.' We create these walls not out of indifference, but out of a twisted form of love, we'd rather hurt now than face what we imagine would be inevitable rejection later. But here's what Nicholas and Princess Mary discover: the people worth loving don't love us for what we can provide or what status we represent. They love us for who we are when the walls come down. The question becomes: are we brave enough to let them see us without our armor?
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion