Pierre cannot sleep. He paces, thinking of Andrew, of Natasha, and of their love, now jealous of her past, now reproaching himself for the jealousy. At six he still walks. Well, what is to be done if it cannot be avoided? He undresses, happy and agitated but free of hesitation. Strange as such happiness seems, he must do everything that she and he may be man and wife. A few days earlier he had meant to go to Petersburg on Friday. Thursday morning Savelich asks about packing. What is Petersburg? Who is there? He puts the journey off. He asks whether Savelich still refuses freedom; the old man says they have never been wronged. Pierre adds, supposing I suddenly marry, it might happen, and Savelich thinks it would be a good thing. How easy he thinks it, Pierre reflects. He does not know how terrible it is, too soon or too late.
At breakfast he tells his cousin he has met Natasha Rostova. She sees nothing extraordinary, mentions a possible match with young Rostov, the Rostovs ruined, Natasha's old affair a pity. Pierre thinks she does not understand. The Chief of Police invites him to send a representative to the Faceted Palace for recovered goods; Pierre looks at the kind, smiling face and cannot believe the talk of bribes. Driving to Mary's to dinner, burned streets look picturesque, like the Rhine and the Colosseum. Cabmen, carpenters, hawkers seem to say, there he is, let's see what will come of it. He doubts last night was real until he feels her presence by the loss of his freedom. She wears the same black dress, yet she is quite different: the child he knew, Andrew's fiancée, a bright questioning light, a strangely roguish look. He dines, leaves with Mary for vespers, comes early next day, and stays so long over trivial talk that Mary feigns a headache.
Alone he asks her to help him. He is not worthy. He cannot propose now, but the thought of missing the possibility is terrible. Can he hope? Mary begins to say that to speak of love is impossible, then stops, having seen Natasha's change. To speak now would not do; leave it to me. I know that she loves, will love you. Write to her parents. Pierre springs up frightened and happy. Go to Petersburg, she says; that will be best. Next day he comes to say good-bye. Natasha is less animated, yet as he looks he sometimes feels that nothing exists but happiness. He holds her thin hand a little longer. Aloud she says good-bye, Count. In a whisper: I shall look forward very much to your return. Those simple words, her look, and her face form for two months the subject of inexhaustible memories. How did she say it? How happy I am.
Andrew's sleepless night reveals something universal: we often avoid the very things that could make us happiest because they require vulnerability. In Tolstoy's time, this meant Andrew avoiding his feelings for Natasha because love meant risk. Today, it looks like the nurse who won't apply for the job she really wants, the father who won't have the hard conversation with his teenager, or the woman who won't leave the relationship that's slowly killing her spirit. We tell ourselves we're being practical, responsible, cautious. But really, we're terrified of disappointment, rejection, or change. The irony is that our avoidance strategies, staying busy, making elaborate plans, focusing on logistics, often create more suffering than the thing we're avoiding. Andrew's planned trip to Petersburg was just another way to run from his feelings, but it would have left him empty and regretful. The breakthrough comes when we stop the motion long enough to name what we're really afraid of. Sometimes the thing that scares us most is exactly what we need to pursue. The question isn't whether we'll face difficult truths eventually, life has a way of forcing our hand. The question is whether we'll face them on our terms or wait until circumstances force us to.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion