At the end of January Pierre goes to Moscow and stays in an unburned annex of his house. He calls on Rostopchin and acquaintances, meaning to leave for Petersburg in two days. The ruined city is bubbling with life. Everyone is pleased to see him and questions him. He feels well disposed, yet instinctively guards himself from new bonds. Where will he live? Will he rebuild? Will he take a parcel? He answers yes, perhaps, or I think so. He has heard the Rostovs are at Kostroma. Natasha seldom occurs to him, and then only as a pleasant memory of the distant past. He feels free even of the feeling he thinks he once aroused in himself.
On the third day he hears from the Drubetskoys that Princess Mary is in Moscow, in the unburned house on Vozdvizhenka Street. Andrew's last days recur with fresh vividness. Driving there that evening he wonders whether Andrew died in the bitter frame of mind of Borodino, whether meaning was disclosed to him, and he compares Andrew with Karataev, so different, both loved. The old footman meets him sternly, as if the prince's absence had not disturbed the order of the house, and says the princess receives on Sundays. Pierre asks to be announced. Dessalles comes: she will see him upstairs.
In a low room lit by one candle sit Mary and another person in black. Pierre takes her for a companion and talks rapidly of Andrew, glancing once at the kindly attentive gaze. When he mentions the Rostovs, Mary's face shows embarrassment. Do you really not recognize her? He looks again at the pale, delicate face, black eyes, peculiar mouth. Something long forgotten and more than sweet looks at him. It cannot be she: this stern, thin, older face. Mary says Natasha. With difficulty, like a door grown rusty, a smile opens, and from that opening comes a breath of fragrance that seizes him. When she smiles, doubt is no longer possible: it is Natasha, and he loves her. He flushes with joyful distress and betrays to her, to Mary, and to himself a secret he had not known. He tries to hide the agitation and only makes it clearer. He failed to notice her because he did not expect her, and failed to recognize her because the change was immense. Thinness was not the point. The face whose eyes had always shone with a suppressed smile of life's joy now held no shadow of a smile, only a kindly, sadly interrogative look. His confusion is not reflected in her, only by pleasure that just perceptibly lights her whole face.
Andrew's story reveals something crucial about how we handle trauma: the same walls that protect us can trap us. After surviving war and loss, he deliberately keeps everyone at emotional distance, thinking he's being smart. But his 'yes, perhaps' responses aren't wisdom, they're armor that's outlived its usefulness. This pattern shows up everywhere in working-class life. Healthcare workers build walls after losing patients, becoming clinically distant even with family. Divorce survivors give vague answers about dating, keeping potential love at arm's length. Parents who've lost custody become emotionally distant from their remaining children, thinking they're preventing further pain but actually creating it. The breakthrough comes when Natasha's smile cuts through Andrew's defenses like they were paper. He didn't plan to fall apart, love just broke through anyway. This teaches us something vital: the crumbling of our walls isn't weakness, it's often the first sign of healing. The key is learning to recognize when protection has become prison, when the armor we built to survive is now preventing us from living.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion