The Fifth Company bivouacs at the forest edge. A huge fire lights frosted branches. About midnight steps crackle in the snow. Someone says a bear. Two strangely clad figures cling to each other and step into the light. They are Frenchmen who have been hiding in the wood, hoarsely uttering a language the soldiers do not understand. The taller wears an officer's hat and falls as he tries to sit. The shorter, sturdy, with a shawl tied round his head, raises him and points to his mouth. The Russians spread a greatcoat, bring buckwheat porridge and vodka. The exhausted officer is Ramballe; the orderly in the shawl is Morel.
Morel drinks, finishes a bowl, and becomes unnaturally merry, chattering to men who cannot follow him. Ramballe refuses food, lies silent with red vacant eyes, and groans. Morel points to his shoulders: the officer must be warmed. A Russian officer sends to the colonel; the colonel will take him. Ramballe rises, staggers, and would fall if a soldier did not hold him. One man winks and mocks; the others rebuke him as a lout and a peasant. They lift Ramballe on crossed arms. He puts his arms round their necks and wails that these are men, his kind friends, leaning his head on a shoulder like a child.
Meanwhile Morel sits in the best place by the fire in a woman's cloak, tipsy, singing Vive Henri Quatre with an arm round the nearest soldier. A wag catches the tune in nonsense syllables. Zaletáev labours after the French words and they roar with laughter. They give Morel a third bowl of porridge: it takes a long time to fill up after starving. Young soldiers smile. Older men lie opposite, thinking such nonsense undignified, yet one raises himself on an elbow and smiles. They are men too, he says, wrapping himself in his coat. Even wormwood grows on its own root. Then they fall silent. The stars, as if knowing no one is looking, flare, vanish, and tremble, whispering something gladsome and mysterious to one another.
Tolstoy shows us something profound about human nature: the categories we use to divide people - enemy/friend, us/them, good/bad - are often just surface constructions that dissolve under real pressure. When those French soldiers stumbled into the Russian camp, they weren't representatives of Napoleon's army anymore. They were just two guys who needed help. The Russian soldiers didn't perform some grand moral calculation - they responded with instinctive human decency. This pattern repeats throughout history and in our daily lives. During Hurricane Katrina, neighbors who had never spoken helped each other regardless of race or politics. In hospitals, the most difficult patients often become the most grateful when they're truly scared. At work, the boss everyone complains about becomes relatable when they're dealing with a family crisis. The key insight is that our shared vulnerabilities - hunger, cold, fear, loneliness - are more fundamental than our constructed differences. When we're reduced to basic human needs, artificial barriers become irrelevant. This doesn't mean we should ignore real conflicts or systemic problems, but it suggests that looking for shared humanity can be a powerful tool for navigation. The next time you find yourself in conflict with someone, try asking: what basic human need or fear might be driving their behavior? What do we actually have in common underneath all the surface differences?
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion