The fifth of November is the first day of what is called the battle of Krasnoe. Toward evening, after generals dispute, miss their places, and send adjutants about with counterorders, it is plain the enemy is in flight and there will be no battle. Kutuzov leaves for Dobroe on a plump little white horse, followed by an enormous suite of discontented generals whispering behind his back. All along the road seven thousand French prisoners crowd to campfires. Near Dobroe tattered men stand beside unharnessed guns. Most have frost-bitten faces and red, festering eyes. Two tear a piece of raw flesh; the one with sores glances malevolently and turns back to the meat. Nearby a Russian pats a Frenchman on the shoulder in a friendly way. Kutuzov screws up his eyes and sways his head, barely hearing the report of captured standards.
He stops before the Preobrazhensk regiment. Thousands of eyes wait. Reluctantly he raises his head and thanks them for hard service: the victory is complete, Russia will not forget, honour forever. He tells a soldier to lower a French eagle before the Russian standards, then shouts Hurrah. While they roar he leans forward, and his eye lights with a mild, apparently ironic gleam. Then voice and face change. It is no longer the commander but an ordinary old man. He knows it is hard; it cannot be helped; they will see the visitors off and rest; the Tsar will not forget. They are at home, while those prisoners are worse than the poorest beggars. While they were strong we did not spare ourselves; now we may even pity them. They are human beings too. Is it not so, lads?
He reads sympathy in the wondering gaze. His face brightens with an old man's smile that clusters wrinkles at lips and eyes. Then he lifts his head: but who asked them here? Serves them right. He flourishes his whip and gallops for the first time in the campaign, leaving broken ranks laughing and shouting. No one could repeat the address that began solemnly and turned into simplehearted talk, yet the sincerity, the triumph mixed with pity, lay in every soldier. Afterwards, asked whether his carriage should be sent for, Kutuzov answers with a sob.
Kutuzov's moment at Krasnoe reveals something profound about leadership that our culture rarely discusses: sometimes doing the right thing still hurts people who don't deserve it. The French soldiers weren't evil, they were young men following orders, now starving and broken far from home. Yet Kutuzov had to defeat them to protect his own people. This tension appears everywhere in working-class life. The union organizer who knows a successful strike will hurt the small business owner barely making ends meet. The nurse who must enforce visiting restrictions that separate families during crises. The teacher who reports neglect knowing it might break up a family that's trying their best. Our culture wants simple stories, good guys versus bad guys, clear victories and defeats. But real leadership often means carrying the weight of complexity, feeling genuine compassion for people you must still act against. Kutuzov shows us that moral leadership isn't about having clean hands, it's about refusing to dehumanize others even when circumstances force conflict. The alternative, shutting down empathy to make decisions easier, creates the kind of callous leadership that treats people as disposable. How do we maintain our humanity while making decisions that inevitably hurt someone?
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion