After the twenty-eighth of October, when the frosts began, the flight of the French assumed a still more tragic character, with men freezing or roasting themselves to death at the campfires, while carriages with people dressed in furs continued to drive past, carrying away the property that had been stolen by the Emperor, kings, and dukes. Yet the process of flight and disintegration went on essentially as before. From Moscow to Vyazma the French army of seventy-three thousand men, not reckoning the Guards, who did nothing during the whole war but pillage, was reduced to thirty-six thousand, though not more than five thousand had fallen in battle. From this beginning the succeeding terms of the progression could be determined mathematically. The army melted away and perished at the same rate from Moscow to Vyazma, from Vyazma to Smolensk, from Smolensk to the Berezina, and from the Berezina to Vilna, independently of the greater or lesser intensity of the cold, the pursuit, the barring of the way, or any other particular conditions. Beyond Vyazma, instead of moving in three columns, it huddled together into one mass, and so went on to the end.
Berthier wrote to his Emperor, and we know how far commanding officers allow themselves to diverge from the truth in describing an army. He deemed it his duty to report the condition of the various corps observed during the last two or three days' march. They were almost disbanded. Scarcely a quarter of the soldiers remained with the standards of their regiments; the others went off by themselves hoping to find food and escape discipline. In general they regarded Smolensk as the place where they hoped to recover. During the last few days many had been seen to throw away their cartridges and their arms. Whatever the ultimate plans, the army should be rallied at Smolensk and freed from ineffectives: dismounted cavalry, unnecessary baggage, artillery no longer in proportion to the present forces. Soldiers worn out with hunger and fatigue needed supplies and a few days' rest. Many had died on the road or at the bivouacs. The state of things was continually becoming worse and made one fear that unless a prompt remedy was applied the troops would no longer be under control in case of an engagement. November the ninth: twenty miles from Smolensk.
After staggering into Smolensk, which seemed to them a promised land, the French, searching for food, killed one another, sacked their own stores, and when everything had been plundered fled farther. They all went without knowing whither or why. Still less did that genius, Napoleon, know it, for no one issued any orders to him. But still he and those about him retained their old habits: wrote commands, letters, reports, and orders of the day; called one another sire, mon cousin, prince d'Eckmuhl, roi de Naples. Those orders and reports were only on paper. Nothing in them was acted upon, for they could not be carried out. Though they entitled one another Majesties, Highnesses, or Cousins, they all felt that they were miserable wretches who had done much evil for which they had now to pay. And though they pretended to be concerned about the army, each was thinking only of himself and of how to get away quickly and save himself.
Tolstoy captures something profound about human psychology in organizational collapse. Napoleon's inner circle weren't stupid, they were intelligent people who understood their desperate situation. Yet they continued the charade of titles and ceremonies even while privately acknowledging they were 'miserable wretches.' Why do smart people participate in obviously failing theater? The answer reveals how power structures maintain themselves even during collapse. Admitting failure means admitting complicity. If you're Berthier writing reports to Napoleon, acknowledging the army's disintegration means acknowledging your role in leading those men to destruction. It's psychologically easier to maintain the performance than face that reality. This dynamic explains why so many organizations, families, and institutions continue dysfunctional patterns long past the point of obvious failure. The people inside aren't necessarily deluded, they're trapped by the social cost of truth-telling. Breaking the performance means accepting responsibility and facing consequences. So they keep writing memos, holding meetings, and using proper titles while everything crumbles. Understanding this pattern helps you recognize when you're witnessing organizational theater versus genuine leadership. Real leaders acknowledge problems early and adapt quickly. Performative leaders increase ceremony and formality as their actual power decreases. The more elaborate the show, the weaker the foundation.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion