The Battle of Borodino, with the occupation of Moscow that followed and the flight of the French without further conflicts, is one of the most instructive phenomena in history. Historians agree that the external activity of states in conflict is expressed in wars, and that as a direct result of greater or less success the political strength of nations increases or decreases. Strange as it may be that a king, having quarrelled, kills three, five, or ten thousand men and subjugates millions, the facts of history as we know them confirm that the greater or lesser success of one army against another is the cause, or at least an essential indication, of an increase or decrease in national strength, even though it is unintelligible why the defeat of a hundredth part of a nation should oblige the whole to submit. Napoleon's wars serve the rule: Austria loses rights in proportion to the defeat of its army; Jena and Auerstadt destroy Prussia's independent existence.
Then, in 1812, the French gain a victory near Moscow. Moscow is taken, and after that, with no further battles, it is not Russia that ceases to exist, but the French army of six hundred thousand, and then Napoleonic France itself. To strain the facts to fit the rules, to say the field of Borodino remained in Russian hands, or that after Moscow there were other battles that destroyed Napoleon's army, is impossible. After the French victory there was no general engagement, nor any that were at all serious, yet the French army ceased to exist. If this were an example from the history of China, historians might say it was not a historic phenomenon. If it concerned a brief conflict with few troops, we might treat it as an exception. This event occurred before our fathers' eyes, a question of the life or death of their fatherland, in the greatest of all known wars. The campaign from Borodino to the expulsion of the French proved that winning a battle does not produce a conquest and is not even an invariable indication of conquest. The force that decides the fate of peoples lies not in the conquerors, nor even in armies and battles, but in something else.
French historians, describing the army before it left Moscow, affirm that all was in order except cavalry, artillery, and transport: there was no forage. That was a misfortune no one could remedy, for the peasants of the district burned their hay rather than let the French have it. Karp and Vlas, who after the evacuation drove into town to pillage and in general failed to manifest heroic feelings, and the whole innumerable multitude of such peasants, did not bring hay for the high price offered, but burned it. Imagine two men fencing with rapiers according to all the rules. Suddenly one, feeling the matter concerns his life, throws down the rapier and seizes a cudgel. Then imagine that the man who used the simplest means, influenced by traditions of chivalry, insisted he had won with the rapier. The fencer who demanded the rules was the French army; the opponent who snatched the cudgel was the Russian people; those who explain by fencing rules are the historians. From the burning of Smolensk a war began that followed no previous traditions. Napoleon complained to Kutuzov and to Alexander that the war was carried on contrary to all the rules, as if there were rules for killing people. Some highly placed Russians also found the cudgel disgraceful and wanted a pose according to the art. The cudgel of the people's war rose and fell with stupid simplicity, and belabored the French till the whole invasion had perished.
Tolstoy shows us something fascinating: the most powerful army in the world defeated by people who refused to be conquered 'properly.' The French expected Russians to surrender after losing battles, to sell supplies to occupying forces, to behave like defeated people. Instead, they burned their own crops, abandoned their towns, and fought with whatever they could find. Napoleon kept complaining that Russians weren't following the rules of warfare, but that was exactly the point. Today we see this pattern everywhere. Employers expect workers to accept whatever conditions they offer because 'people need jobs.' Landlords expect tenants to pay whatever rent they demand because 'people need housing.' Politicians expect voters to choose between bad options because 'that's how democracy works.' But what happens when people stop accepting these premises? When healthcare workers refuse mandatory overtime, when tenants organize rent strikes, when voters reject both major parties? The powerful always complain that people aren't playing fair, but there are no rules that say you have to participate in your own oppression. The Russian peasants understood something we're relearning: sometimes the only way to win is to refuse to play the game entirely. The question isn't whether you have the right to change the rules, it's whether you have the courage to stop following rules that were never designed to serve you.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion