LIVE
OCD← Home
War and Peace cover
1869
War and Peace
Leo Tolstoy · When Plans Meet Reality
Chapter 286
Ch. 285
Reading
Ch. 286
Ch. 287
Loading audio...
0:000:00

Meanwhile another column was to have attacked the French from the front, but Kutuzov accompanied that column. He well knew that nothing but confusion would come of a battle undertaken against his will, and as far as he could he held the troops back. He rode silently on his small grey horse, indolently answering suggestions that they should attack. To Miloradovich, who asked permission to advance, he said the word attack was always on their tongues, yet they could not execute complicated manoeuvres. They had failed to take Murat that morning or even to reach the place in time; nothing could be done now. When he was told that two battalions of Poles had appeared at the French rear, where Cossacks had reported nobody, he gave a sidelong glance at Ermolov, to whom he had not spoken since the previous day. They asked to attack and made plans of all kinds, he said, but as soon as one got to business nothing was ready, and the enemy, forewarned, took measures. Ermolov smiled faintly, understanding that the storm had blown over for him, and later remarked respectfully that it was not too late, that the Guards would not so much as see a little smoke.

Kutuzov did not reply. When they reported Murat in retreat he ordered an advance, though at every hundred paces he halted for three quarters of an hour. The whole battle consisted in what Orlov-Denisov's Cossacks had done; the rest of the army merely lost some hundreds of men uselessly. In consequence Kutuzov received a diamond decoration, Bennigsen diamonds and a hundred thousand rubles, others pleasant recognitions by grade, and the staff was reshuffled again. Russian officers said everything was done topsy-turvy, as if some fool were in charge and they themselves would have done it right.

People who talk like that, Tolstoy says, either do not know or deceive themselves. No battle, Tarutino, Borodino, or Austerlitz, takes place as those who planned it anticipated. That is an essential condition. Countless free forces, for nowhere is a man freer than where life and death are in question, influence the fight, and the course never coincides with any one force, any more than a body acted on by many forces moves along a single line. If historians, especially French ones, describe wars carried out according to previously formed plans, those descriptions are false. Tarutino did not achieve Toll's order, Orlov's capture of Murat, Bennigsen's destruction of a corps, an officer's distinction, or a Cossack's extra booty. If the aim was what all Russians that day desired, to drive the French out and destroy their army, the incongruous battle was exactly what was wanted: with little effort and slight losses it made the transition from retreat to advance, exposed French weakness, and gave Napoleon's army the shock it had only awaited before beginning its flight.

Amplified Discussion
Tarutino Verdict

Chapter seven: Kutuzov restraint, Ermolov glance, decorations, free forces parallelogram, incongruity as wanted result. Andrew should hold mean force result through partisan chapters ahead. Andrew should hold mean force result through partisan war chapters ahead. Tolstoy shows how private feeling survives when public language hardens around it. Tolstoy shows how private feeling survives when public language hardens around it. Tolstoy shows how private feeling survives when public language hardens around it.

Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.

AI Discussion
Why it matters

Reading Messy Outcomes

Kutuzov holds back; no battle matches plan; Tarutino incongruities achieve retreat-to-advance transition. Ask what simple rest you crave after overload. Reading Messy Outcomes maps Andrew's road through Tarutino chaos.

Lessons

PracticeThis week, notice a chaotic result that still served the larger aim.

Psych reading

Mean Force Result

Tarutino fails every planner's aim yet achieves retreat-to-advance transition through mean of free forces and incongruous success.

In the mind

Kutuzov holds back; battle reduces to Cossack raid plus useless losses; planners get decorations anyway.

The mechanism: countless free forces produce diagonal mean, not any one commander's vector.

You see it when Tarutino's chaos achieves campaign aim planners missed.

Incongruity can be the opportune result when mass desire aligns.

Find the right chapter

Each mood maps to a life skill. Each skill connects to the patterns in classic literature.

😔How do you feel😊

Personalize your match

Optional—life stage, what you need today, and what you're navigating help us pick chapters that fit—not generic lists. You may also freeform using the feeling search below.

Sign in to save your profile

Choices stay on this device until you sign in.

Browse the Full Library
4,582Chapters
118+Books
86Authors