Nine days after the abandonment of Moscow, a messenger from Kutuzov reached Petersburg with the official announcement. This was Michaud, a Frenchman who did not know Russian, but who said of himself that though a foreigner he was Russian in heart and soul. The Emperor received him at once in his study at the palace on Stone Island. Michaud had never seen Moscow before the campaign, yet he felt deeply moved, as he later wrote, appearing before the sovereign with news of the burning city whose flames had lit his road.
The Emperor, seeing his sad face, asked if he had brought sad news. Very sad, sire: the abandonment of Moscow. Had they surrendered the ancient capital without a battle? Michaud delivered Kutuzov's message: it had been impossible to fight before Moscow; the remaining choice was to lose the army as well as the city, or the city alone, and the field marshal had chosen the latter. The Emperor listened in silence, not looking at him. Had the enemy entered? Yes, sire, and Moscow was now in ashes; Michaud had left it all in flames. Then, frightened by the effect, he watched the Emperor breathe heavily, his lower lip tremble, tears appear in his fine blue eyes. It lasted only a moment. Alexander frowned as if blaming himself for weakness, raised his head, and said that Providence required great sacrifices and that he was ready to submit, but how had Michaud left the army? Had he noticed discouragement?
Michaud asked leave to speak frankly, to gain time, then said he had left the whole army, from chiefs to the lowest soldier, in desperate and agonized terror. The Emperor interrupted: would misfortune make his Russians lose heart? Never. Michaud had waited for that. They were only afraid, he said with respectful playfulness, that His Majesty in the goodness of his heart might be persuaded to make peace. They were burning for combat. The Emperor, reassured, patted his shoulder. He drew himself up and told Michaud to go back and tell the brave men that when he had not a soldier left he would put himself at the head of his nobility and peasants. Should Providence ordain that his dynasty cease to reign, then after exhausting every means he would let his beard grow to his chest and eat potatoes with the meanest of his peasants rather than sign the disgrace of his country. He turned away as if to hide tears, came back, pressed Michaud's arm, and said: Napoleon or I. They could no longer both reign. He had learned to know him, and would not be deceived again. Michaud, at that solemn moment, felt himself the representative of the Russian people. Your Majesty, he said, is at this moment signing the glory of the nation and the salvation of Europe. With an inclination of the head the Emperor dismissed him.
Chapter three gives Alexander's Stone Island scene: capital surrendered, ashes, Providence, beard vow, Napoleon or I, Michaud's glory line. Andrew should contrast Petersburg bubble with this performed resolve. Andrew should hear Michaud craft fear-of-peace line for Alexander's reassurance. Tolstoy shows how private feeling survives when public language hardens around it. Tolstoy shows how private feeling survives when public language hardens around it.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion