When Ermolov, sent by Kutuzov to inspect the position, tells the field marshal that it is impossible to fight there before Moscow and that they must retreat, Kutuzov looks at him in silence. Give me your hand, he says, and, turning it over so as to feel the pulse, adds that Ermolov is not well: think what you are saying. Kutuzov cannot yet admit the possibility of retreating beyond Moscow without a battle. On Poklonny Hill, four miles from the Dorogomilov gate, he gets out of his carriage and sits on a bench by the roadside. A great crowd of generals gathers round him, and Count Rostopchin, who has come out from Moscow, joins them. Though they have not been summoned for the purpose, they all feel that this is really a council of war. Conversations deal with public questions. Personal news is whispered, then they revert to general matters. There are no jokes, no laughter, no smiles. All make an effort to hold themselves at the height the situation demands, and all try to keep near the commander in chief and speak so that he may overhear. He listens, sometimes asks them to repeat, but does not himself take part or express an opinion. After hearing a group he generally turns away with an air of disappointment, as though they were not speaking of anything he wished to hear.
Some criticise not so much the chosen position as the mental capacity of those who chose it. Others argue that a battle should have been fought two days before. Crosart, a newly arrived Frenchman in a Spanish uniform, describes Salamanca, and he and a German prince consider whether Moscow might be defended like Saragossa. Rostopchin tells a fourth group that he is prepared to die with the city train bands under the walls, but regrets having been left in ignorance. A fifth group discusses the direction the troops must now take. A sixth talks absolute nonsense. From all this talk Kutuzov's expression grows more preoccupied and gloomy. He sees only one thing: to defend Moscow is a physical impossibility in the full meaning of those words, so utterly impossible that if any senseless commander gave orders to fight, confusion would result but the battle would still not take place. It would not take place because the commanders not merely all recognise the position as impossible, but in their conversations are only discussing what will happen after its inevitable abandonment. How could they lead troops to a field they consider impossible to hold? The lower-grade officers and even the soldiers, who too reason, also consider the position impossible and therefore could not go to fight, fully convinced as they are of defeat.
If Bennigsen insists on defence and others still discuss it, the question is no longer important in itself but only as a pretext for disputes and intrigue. This Kutuzov knows well. Bennigsen, who chose the position, warmly displays his Russian patriotism, Kutuzov cannot listen without wincing, by insisting that Moscow must be defended. His aim is as clear as daylight: if the defence fails, to throw the blame on Kutuzov, who brought the army as far as the Sparrow Hills without giving battle; if it succeeds, to claim the success as his own; or if battle is not given, to clear himself of the crime of abandoning Moscow. But this intrigue does not now occupy the old man's mind. One terrible question absorbs him, and to that question he hears no reply from anyone. Have I really allowed Napoleon to reach Moscow, and when did I do so? Yesterday, when I ordered Platov to retreat? The evening before, when I had a nap and told Bennigsen to issue orders? Or earlier still? Moscow must be abandoned. The army must retreat, and the order to do so must be given. To give that terrible order seems to him equivalent to resigning the command. He loves power, and the honours awarded to Prince Prozorovski, under whom he served in Turkey, still gall him. He is convinced that he is destined to save Russia, that against the Emperor's wish and by the will of the people he was chosen, that he alone can encounter invincible Napoleon without fear. He is horrified at the thought of the order he has to issue. Something has to be decided, and these conversations, assuming too free a character, must be stopped. He calls the most important generals to him. My head, be it good or bad, must depend on itself, he says, rising from the bench, and he rides to Fili, where his carriages are waiting.
Chapter three is Kutuzov's solitary dread: Ermolov rebuffed, Bennigsen scheming, Poklonny talk after impossibility is known, when did I allow Napoleon. Andrew should read the retreat order as long foreseen, not sudden cowardice. Andrew should read Fili as the next step after Poklonny talk already assumed abandonment. Bennigsen's patriotism was cover for shifting fault if defense failed at Sparrow Hills.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion