LIVE
OCD← Home
War and Peace cover
1869
War and Peace
Leo Tolstoy · When Perfect Plans Meet Reality
Chapter 217
Ch. 216
Reading
Ch. 217
Ch. 218
Loading audio...
0:000:00

On the twenty-fifth of August, so his historians tell us, Napoleon spent the whole day on horseback inspecting the locality, considering plans submitted by his marshals, and personally giving commands to his generals. The original Russian line along the Kolocha had been dislocated by the capture of the Shevardino Redoubt on the twenty-fourth, and the left flank drawn back. That part was not entrenched, and in front of it the ground was more open and level. It was evident to anyone, military or not, that it was here the French should attack. It would seem that not much consideration was needed, nor that special quality called genius that people ascribe to Napoleon; yet the historians, the men around him, and he himself thought otherwise.

He rode over the plain with a profound air and in silence, nodded with approval or shook his head dubiously, and without communicating the course of ideas which guided his decisions gave only final conclusions as commands. Having listened to Davout, now Prince d'Eckmuhl, on turning the Russian left wing, he said it should not be done, without explaining why. To General Campan, who was to attack the fleches, he agreed that the division should go through the woods, though Ney, the so-called Duke of Elchingen, remarked that a movement through woods was dangerous and might disorder the division. After inspecting the country opposite Shevardino he indicated spots for two batteries by the morrow against the Russian entrenchments, and places for field artillery in line with them. Then he returned to his tent, and the dispositions were written down from his dictation.

Those dispositions, of which French historians write with enthusiasm and others with profound respect, related to four points. Not one of them was, or could be, carried out. First, batteries on the spot he chose, with the guns of Pernetti and Fouche, 102 guns in all, were to shower shells on the Russian fleches and redoubts. From the spots selected the projectiles did not carry, and those guns shot into the air until the nearest commander, contrary to instructions, moved them forward. Second, Poniatowski, moving to the village through the wood, should turn the Russian left. He met Tuchkov barring his way and could not and did not turn the position. Third, Campan would move through the wood to seize the first fortification. His division was driven back, for on emerging it had to reform under grapeshot, of which Napoleon was unaware. Fourth, the vice-King would occupy Borodino, cross by its three bridges, and with Morand and Gerard advance on the redoubt. After passing through Borodino the vice-King was driven back to the Kolocha; Morand and Gerard did not take the redoubt, which was taken only at the end of the battle by the cavalry, a thing probably unforeseen and not heard of by Napoleon. The disposition said that after the fight had commenced in this manner, orders would be given in accordance with the enemy's movements. That could not be done either, for during the whole battle Napoleon was so far away that, as appeared later, he could not know the course of the fight, and not one of his orders during it could be executed.

Amplified Discussion
The Unrun Orders

Chapter twenty-seven is Tolstoy's demolition of battle-as-chess. Batteries fire short, Poniatowski meets Tuchkov, Campan reforms under grapeshot. Andrew should read Napoleon's silence as theater and the dispositions as history written before the guns spoke. Andrew should treat ornate orders as hypotheses until the field confirms them. Pierre is absent here; the chapter is pure Tolstoy on command mythology at Borodino.

Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.

AI Discussion
Why it matters

Testing Plans on Contact

Napoleon's four disposition orders none execute as written. When a plan looks perfect in headquarters, ask what breaks once distance and smoke arrive. Test whether commands survive distance before you praise the disposition deck.

Lessons

PracticeThis week, trace one polished plan to what actually happened on the ground.

Psych reading

Plans Versus Reality

Elaborate battle plans impress historians and staffs but fail when terrain, distance, and independent action undo each order.

In the mind

Napoleon's Borodino dispositions read like genius yet none of four key orders execute.

The mechanism: ornate plans impress staffs while distance and terrain undo them in minutes.

You see it when polished decks meet a field that ignores the timeline.

Respect preparation but test whether commands can survive contact and proximity.

Find the right chapter

Each mood maps to a life skill. Each skill connects to the patterns in classic literature.

😔How do you feel😊

Personalize your match

Optional—life stage, what you need today, and what you're navigating help us pick chapters that fit—not generic lists. You may also freeform using the feeling search below.

Sign in to save your profile

Choices stay on this device until you sign in.

Browse the Full Library
4,582Chapters
118+Books
86Authors