Natasha is calmer but no happier. She avoids balls, promenades, concerts, and theatres. She never laughs without tears in the sound and cannot sing. Laughter and singing feel like blasphemy against remorse, against the pure times that will not return, and against a young life she thinks she has ruined. No wish to coquet enters her head. No man is more to her than Nastasya Ivanovna the buffoon. Something stands sentinel and forbids every joy. The hunting, Uncle, and Christmas at Otradnoe with Nicholas return most painfully. She tries not to be a burden, wants nothing, and is at ease only with Petya, with whom she sometimes laughs.
Of visitors she is glad only of Pierre. Count Bezukhov treats her with more delicacy, care, and seriousness than anyone. She feels it and takes pleasure in his company, but does not even feel grateful, because kindness seems natural in him. She attributes his awkwardness to general shyness. After the involuntary words that if he were free he would have asked on his knees for her hand, he never speaks of his feelings. She takes those words as comfort spoken to a crying child. It is not because he is married, but because she feels with him the moral barrier she lacked with Kuragin, that she never imagines love or a self-conscious romantic friendship.
Before the end of the fast of St. Peter, country neighbour Agrafena Ivanovna Belova comes to Moscow for the shrines and proposes fasting and preparation for Holy Communion. Natasha welcomes it. Despite the doctor's orders not to go out early, she insists on going to church every day for a week, missing neither Vespers, Matins, nor Mass, not the family's three household services. The countess, hoping prayer may help more than medicine, conceals the plan from the doctor and entrusts her to Belova. Belova finds her already awake at three. In her shabbiest dress Natasha stands before an icon of the Blessed Virgin at a church whose priest Belova calls severe. When she understands the words her feeling weaves into the prayers. When she does not, it is sweeter to think that wanting to understand everything is pride, and she asks God to forgive her everything. Repentance prayers hold her most. On the way home among bricklayers she feels a new life may be possible. After communion on Sunday, in white muslin, she feels calm for the first time in months. The doctor still orders the powders of a fortnight ago, pockets his gold, and says the last medicine has freshened her. The countess looks at her nails and spits a little for luck.
Chapter seventeen pairs inner sentinel with outer ritual. Belova wakes her at three; repentance prayers matter most; communion Sunday brings calm. Pierre's gentleness stays in the background. The doctor pockets gold and claims the powders worked. Andrew should copy structure and presence, not the doctor's vanity. Pierre's gentleness stays in the background while the doctor pockets gold and claims the powders worked.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion