LIVE
OCD← Home
War and Peace cover
1869
War and Peace
Leo Tolstoy · The Dangerous Expert
Chapter 177
Ch. 176
Reading
Ch. 177
Ch. 178
Loading audio...
0:000:00

Shishkóv's letter has not yet been presented when Barclay, at dinner, tells Bolkónski that the sovereign wishes to question him about Turkey at Bennigsen's quarters at six. That same day news arrives of a fresh French movement that might endanger the army, news afterwards found to be false. That morning Colonel Michaud has ridden the Drissa fortifications with the Emperor and pointed out that Pfuel's camp, till then a chef-d'oeuvre that would ensure Napoleon's destruction, is an absurdity threatening the destruction of the Russian army.

Prince Andrew arrives at a moderate country house on the river. Neither Bennigsen nor the Emperor is there. Chernýshev, the Emperor's aide-de-camp, sitting at a window with a French novel, says they have gone a second time to inspect the camp, about which serious doubts are beginning to be felt. In the next room, not a military council (the Emperor prefers indefiniteness) but persons whose opinions he wishes to know: Armfeldt, Wolzogen, Wintzingerode, Michaud, Toll, Stein, and Pfuel, the mainspring of the whole affair. An adjutant dozes on rolled bedding beside an organ piled with rugs.

Pfuel arrives soon after Andrew, in an ill-made Russian general's uniform that fits like a fancy costume. Short, thin, broad-boned, deep-set eyes, hair hastily brushed at the temples and sticking up in tufts behind, he looks restlessly around as if afraid of the large apartment, holding his sword awkwardly, wanting only to reach a map. Chernýshev introduces Andrew as just back from Turkey, where the war ended fortunately. Pfuel barely glances past him, laughs that it must have been a fine tactical war, and goes on. He is particularly disturbed that they have dared inspect his camp in his absence. Andrew, thanks to Austerlitz, reads him at once: more typical than Weyrother, Mack, or Schmidt, self-confident to martyrdom on the basis of an abstract science, the theory of oblique movements deduced from Frederick the Great. Later wars seem to him barbarous collisions that cannot serve as material. He was among those responsible for the 1806 plan that ended at Jena, yet saw no proof of fallibility: deviations caused the disaster, and he remarks with gleeful sarcasm that he said the whole affair would go to the devil. He loves theory so much that he hates the practical, and is even pleased by failures, which only prove the theory. He says a few words about the present war as a man who knows beforehand that all will go wrong and is not displeased. The unbrushed tufts express it. He passes into the next room, and his deep querulous voice is heard at once.

Amplified Discussion
Pfuel at Headquarters

Chapter ten is Andrew's cold read of expertise without experience. Barclay summons him; false Napoleon news buzzes; Michaud has already told the Emperor the Drissa camp is catastrophe dressed as science. Pfuel passes through with tufts of hair and a laugh about Turkey as fine tactical war. Tolstoy's national catalog is comic and sharp: French charm, English institution, Russian indifference, German science mistaken for truth. Pfuel loves theory more than outcomes and greets failure as proof others were stupid. Andrew, fresh from Austerlitz memory, sees fall coming. Andrew's UN arc should log the screening question: who has paid for being wrong here? Institutions promote planners who never stand in the rain of their own orders. Your mission rooms and hospitals and shelters all have a Pfuel somewhere. Do not confuse contempt for practitioners with wisdom. Watch who celebrates chaos as training problem. That is the map for chapter ten and for any room where maps matter more than mud.

Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.

AI Discussion
Why it matters

Screening Theoretical Experts

Bad plans can arrive with medals on them. Michaud shows Andrew that Pfuel's Drissa masterpiece is an absurdity, and Pfuel still treats deviation as the only possible error. Before you adopt a new system, ask who has operated inside it when it failed.

Lessons

PracticeFor one live policy, name the last person who did the work, not only who designed the slide deck.

Psych reading

The Untested Expert

People who design systems they never operate become confidently wrong because consequences never touch their identity.

In the mind

Pfuel is dangerous because failure never reaches his theory, only the people who deviate from it.

The mechanism is intellectual pride without skin in the game: elaborate plans, contempt for practitioners, celebration when others stumble.

You see it when consultants redesign work they have never done and blame rollout when harm appears.

Ask who has lived inside the problem before you let them move your army.

Find the right chapter

Each mood maps to a life skill. Each skill connects to the patterns in classic literature.

😔How do you feel😊

Personalize your match

Optional—life stage, what you need today, and what you're navigating help us pick chapters that fit—not generic lists. You may also freeform using the feeling search below.

Sign in to save your profile

Choices stay on this device until you sign in.

Browse the Full Library
4,582Chapters
118+Books
86Authors