Pierre drives to Márya Dmítrievna's to report that Kurágin has been banished. The house is in alarm. Natásha is very ill: the night after she was told Anatole was married she swallowed a little arsenic she had stealthily procured, then was so frightened that she woke Sónya. Antidotes were given in time; she is out of danger but too weak to move to the country, so the countess has been sent for. Pierre sees the distracted count and tear-stained Sónya, but not Natásha.
At the Club that day gossip of the attempted abduction is everywhere. Pierre resolutely denies it, assuring everyone that nothing happened except that his brother-in-law proposed and was refused. He believes it his duty to conceal the affair and re-establish her name. He dreads Andrew's return and goes every day to the old prince for news. Old Prince Bolkónski has heard the town rumours from Bourienne and has read Natásha's note breaking the engagement; he seems in better spirits and awaits his son with impatience. Some days after Anatole's departure Pierre receives a note that Andrew has arrived.
Pierre expects to find him as shattered as Natásha, and is surprised to hear a loud animated voice in the study arguing about Speránski's sudden exile. Mary comes out, sighs toward the door, and is plainly glad both at what happened and at how her brother has taken it: he says he expected it; his pride will not let him show feeling. Andrew, healthier, in civilian dress, a fresh horizontal wrinkle between his brows, is disputing with his father and Prince Meshchérski. At the sight of Pierre his face quivers into a vindictive look, then he asks if Pierre is still getting stouter. The smile says he is well, but his health is of no use to anyone. After roads, Switzerland, and tutor Dessalles, he returns to justice for Speránski. Pierre recognizes the need to argue extraneous matters in order to stifle what is too intimate. Alone, Andrew hands over Natásha's letters and portrait to return, smiles like his father about her illness, asks where Kurágin is, snorts that he did not honour her with his hand, and, when Pierre recalls their Petersburg talk of forgiving a fallen woman, says he said such a woman should be forgiven, not that he could forgive. If Pierre wishes to be his friend, never mention her again. Mary is quietly glad. At dinner Andrew talks without stopping, now with his father, now with Dessalles, about the coming war.
Chapter twenty-one splits catastrophe in two bodies. Natasha's arsenic is shame turned lethal; Sonya's vigil saves her, and the house sends for the countess. Pierre becomes reputation shield at the club, rewriting abduction into refused proposal because Moscow eats girls alive. Andrew's return is the other pole: health improved, eyes hard, voice loud on Speranski while Natasha's packet waits in his hand. Princess Mary is almost relieved; the old prince thrives on rumor. Pierre sees contempt for the Rostovs and understands Andrew uses politics like a furnace to burn feeling. The forgiveness speech from Petersburg now rots into I cannot. Andrew's UN lesson for mediators: displacement and righteous cruelty feel like strength and leave everyone colder. War talk at dinner hints history will soon dwarf this wound, but Tolstoy insists private cruelty matters now. Protect the living girl even when the wronged man has a right to leave.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion