In the sitting room Natásha asks Nicholas whether he ever feels that everything good is past. He answers with the sudden sadness he knew in the regiment when music played without him, and the thought that they must all die. They recall her punishment over plums, a Negro in the dark study of the old house whom their parents say never existed, hard-boiled eggs rolling in the ballroom, two old women spinning on the carpet, and Papa firing a gun in the porch. Sónya cannot quite keep pace except when they remember her first arrival and the nurse's warning about cords. A maid whispers that the cock has come; Natásha sends it away.
Dimmler uncovers the harp. The countess calls for her favourite Field nocturne. The young people discuss dreams and metempsychosis by moonlight after Natásha carries out the candle. She is certain they were angels somewhere and have been here, which is why they remember; Nicholas objects that they have not fallen lower. The countess calls Natásha to sing. Standing where the resonance is best, she sings as she has not sung in a long time. The count blunders in his talk with steward Mítenka. Sónya feels the immense difference between herself and her cousin. The countess, blissful and afraid, thinks there is something unnatural in the coming marriage to Prince Andrew. Dimmler says it is a European talent. Fourteen-year-old Pétya rushes in about mummers; Natásha screams idiot, throws herself sobbing on a chair, then tries to smile.
House serfs dressed as bears, Turks, innkeepers, and ladies crowd in from the cold. The young people disappear and return: Nicholas as an old lady in a hooped skirt, Pétya a Turkish girl, Dimmler a clown, Natásha a hussar, Sónya a Circassian with burnt-cork mustache. The countess forbids a visit to Uncle and a bad leg keeps the count home. Madame Schoss consents to chaperone a drive to widow Melyukóva, three miles away. Four troykas race through moonlit snow. Nicholas sees a new sweet face under Sónya's sable hood, overtakes Zakhár on the highroad, and finds the familiar Kosóy meadow turned enchanted before maids with candles run out at Melyukóvka.
Tolstoy stacks registers in one chapter. The sitting room begins with Natasha's fear that everything good is past, and Nicholas answers with regiment melancholy beside real cheer. Shared memory follows: the Negro who may be dream, innocent plums, the count firing in the blue overcoat. Sonya cannot keep pace but belongs at the edge. Dimmler plays while they whisper about souls and eternity until the countess demands a song that breaks Natasha when Petya shouts. Then mummers, costumes, refusal of the cock, and troykas into frost. Nicholas peers at Sonya and thinks that used to be Sonya while heaven only knows where they drive. The lesson for Andrew abroad is not to treat depth and delight as rivals. Mission culture favors one face. Tolstoy says the fullest humanity holds philosophical children and racing heirs in the same house. If you are Andrew, let the enchanted road teach you that meaning sometimes returns when you stop hunting it alone and let the mask show you who was already near.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion