Again Pierre is overtaken by the depression he so dreads. For three days after the delivery of his speech at the lodge he lies on a sofa at home receiving no one and going nowhere. Just then he receives a letter from his wife, who implores him to see her, telling him how grieved she is about him and how she wishes to devote her whole life to him. At the end she informs him that in a few days she will return to Petersburg from abroad. Following this letter one of the Masonic Brothers whom Pierre respects less than the others forces his way in and, turning the conversation upon Pierre's matrimonial affairs, by way of fraternal advice expresses the opinion that his severity to his wife is wrong and that he is neglecting one of the first rules of Freemasonry by not forgiving the penitent. At the same time his mother-in-law, Prince Vasíli's wife, sends imploring him to come if only for a few minutes to discuss a most important matter. Pierre sees that there is a conspiracy against him and that they want to reunite him with his wife, and in the mood he then is, this is not even unpleasant. Nothing matters. Nothing in life seems of much importance, and under the depression he values neither his liberty nor his resolution to punish his wife. No one is right and no one is to blame, so she too is not to blame. If he does not at once consent, it is only because he does not feel able to take any step. Had she come to him, he would not have turned her away.
Without replying either to his wife or his mother-in-law, Pierre late one night prepares for a journey and starts for Moscow to see Joseph Alexéevich. In his diary, Moscow, 17th November, he hastens to write what he has experienced. His benefactor is living poorly and has for three years been suffering from a painful disease of the bladder. No one has ever heard him utter a groan or a word of complaint. From morning till late at night, except when he eats his very plain food, he is working at science. He receives Pierre graciously on the bed on which he lies. Pierre makes the sign of the Knights of the East and of Jerusalem; Joseph Alexéevich responds with a mild smile, asking what he has learned in the Prussian and Scottish lodges. Pierre tells everything, including the Petersburg proposal and the bad reception. The teaching he brings away is that the chief aim of our order is to purify and regenerate ourself, not to chase mysteries or reform mankind while remaining personally dissolute. Worldly cares, including marriage, are the laboratory.
Back in Petersburg, in perplexity, not knowing whose aid to seek, Pierre rereads the letters and recalls the conversations. He ought not to refuse a supplicant; he ought to reach a helping hand to everyone, especially to one so closely bound to him; he must bear his cross. But if he forgives her for the sake of doing right, then let union have only a spiritual aim. That is what he decides, and what he writes to Joseph Alexéevich. He tells his wife that he begs her to forget the past, to forgive him whatever wrong he may have done her, and that he had nothing to forgive. It gives him joy to tell her this. She need not know how hard it was for him to see her again. He settles on the upper floor of the big house and is experiencing a happy feeling of regeneration.
Pierre's Moscow visit contains real wisdom: self-purification matters more than Illuminist world schemes. Yet his Petersburg ending shows how quickly insight becomes costume when social machines restart. He forgives, separates floors, and calls it regeneration while the marriage remains strategic calm, not renewed love. That is spiritual bypassing in aristocratic dress. The chapter asks whether your practices increase contact with reality or rename surrender. Joseph Alexéevich's illness and patience model work without performance; Pierre's diary will soon show the gap. For readers today, the test is similar: does your mindfulness, service ethic, or forgiveness language change boundaries and behavior, or only your self-story? Depression plus community pressure is a high-risk window. Treat major recommitments like surgery: wait until you can feel stakes again, then choose with eyes open.
Explore this chapter with AI to uncover deeper meaning and practical takeaways.
AI Discussion